Home
Feature Article
MLB 09: The Show - The System Seller?

Can you believe that it is already March? March Madness is right around the corner, the NBA and NHL playoff chases are beginning to intensify, and the chill of winter will (hopefully) subside soon and give way to the warmth of spring.

And by now, many gamers are already playing the newest round of baseball titles for 2009, MLB 09: The Show and MLB 2K9 -- a sign that MLB Opening Day is on the horizon.

But because of the unfortunate gulf of quality between MLB 2K and The Show, there are probably many baseball fans, sports gamers and Xbox 360 owners presently battling with that ultimate question -- one that I have also been admittedly battling with. And that question is, "should I really spend hundreds of dollars on a PS3 just for one game?"

 


Is MLB 09: The Show worth a purchase of a new system?

True Marks of Greatness

Look, I am certainly no mathematician or rocket scientist, but I do understand what a killer app is and what elements it contains. For those who are not familiar with the term, a killer application or "killer app" is a computing term usually used to describe a unique feature or a piece of software -- or in this case a video game -- that causes people to buy the hardware it runs on just to own/play/experience it. These are typically your Marios, GTAs, Halos or Final Fantasys.

But how does The Show fit into that group? Well, it does and it does not

For one, I am not totally delirious, and I am not suggesting that The Show will ever approach the sales of a Mario game or something like a Gears of War. Nevertheless, The Show still possesses some unique attributes that ensure its place as a killer app for many sports fans.

The attributes I am hinting at are exclusivity and quality.

Seems simple, right? Well, it is. And if you go through any list of killer apps over the years, you will probably find that almost all of those titles possess those same traits. Exclusivity alone is why companies like EA, Sony and Microsoft are willing to pay millions to arrange for exclusive rights to an existing series, popular commodity, and yes, even a sports league or association. But the second portion, quality, well, that part is a bit harder to nail. And that is why The Show is in the position it is in at the moment.

Sony’s Real Killer App?

So how does The Show fit into those two categories? Well, the first, exclusivity, speaks for itself. As a game developed by SCE, The Show is essentially a Sony product and has been since its days on the PSone. In the past, though, baseball games were considerably more abundant, and fans had many more choices. At one point, there were a huge number of games out there to buy and play: Triple Play, All-Star Baseball, High Heat Baseball, Inside Pitch, the various 2K releases and probably a host of others I am forgetting.

But now, thanks to a marketplace growing ever more competitive and expensive, and the various licensing battles between 2K and EA, we are now left with two main baseball titles -- or three if you count Power Pros -- to fight it out for sandbox supremacy. And, unfortunately, for a few years now it has been a rather one-sided battle.

Now that is not to say I am totally discounting 2K’s offerings, but it is tough to succeed when you are competing against such stiff competition -- just ask the Blue Jays how they feel about being in the AL East.

Anyway, that also leads me to my next criterion, quality. And boy, does The Show excel in that department. For five years now, we have watched this series grow and blossom, and now it is one of the best sports series available today. Truthfully, I have been enjoying the series since before The Show even became a part of the name. (Maybe one day I will tell you all the story of how I literally trudged through a rough Toronto winter storm to pick up a PSP copy of MLB 2005.)

Simply put, it is a great series that has shown others how to properly manage and develop an exclusive franchise. In addition, The Show’s PS2 and PSP offerings still manage to attract loads of admirers to this day. It is important not to overlook that fact because those games are an integral part of the franchise’s overall success: If you put out a quality product for multiple years, you generate a loyal fan base. In other words, those players that get hooked on the PS2 and PSP versions will inevitably get the itch to play the "best" version of the game on the PS3.

So enter 2007, when the series made the leap to the PS3. This was the pivotal point when things really took off for the series. With the addition of truly realistic graphics, retention of the solid-as-a-rock gameplay, and a load of other fantastic and innovative features, The Show on the PS3 instantly became a game of real significance, and it instantly became a benchmark for sports gaming. Well, that all sounds pretty awesome, right?

Great game, I would sure love to play it. But to enjoy any of it, of course I would need a PS3 first.


So really, is MLB 09: The Show worth buying a PS3 for?

What’s Past Is Past

In a way, The Show is really the last of a dying breed. Real exclusivity has become somewhat of a rarity these days. Many third-party titles, including some former rock-solid exclusives like Final Fantasy, have become available on a multitude of platforms these days.

Even so, looking back at gaming history as a whole, when have sports games ever been a real killer app on par with the likes of Zelda, MGS or Halo? Looking back on it, Nintendo’s first-party sports offerings, which have usually been pretty Mario-centric, have been mostly good quality titles, but they have hardly met the hardcore sim standards that many seek.

On the other hand, Microsoft’s games on the Xbox were perfectly suited for the hardcore crowd, but I do not believe many people solely bought an Xbox just for Links, NBA Inside Drive, Top Spin, NFL Fever or NHL Rivals -- yet I admit that I bought my old Xbox used just to play Inside Drive 2003. And before The Show arrived, Sony’s mostly 989-developed offerings (NFL GameDay and NBA Shootout) were average to mediocre at best, hardly system sellers.

I suppose the 2K games on the Dreamcast were nice exclusives as NFL/NBA 2K were such a step above what else was available at the time. But on the other hand, the Dreamcast's total lack of EA games was seen as a boon for the Playstation and has been pointed to as one of the causes for the premature death of Sega’s last console.

Of course through the course of all this, I have been skipping over the best-selling sports app of all in Madden. It obviously has got the exclusivity portion figured out -- in a different sense of course -- and the series has been a quality product at times I suppose.

But Madden is on a different plane of existence than The Show. I mean, Madden is available on every platform imaginable and it is really the only football game in town at the moment. But even then, I still do not imagine that many gamers have bought their current-gen console of choice just to sample the latest flavor of Madden.

At the very least, Madden is really not comparable to what is going on with The Show right now. And with The Show in such a unique position at the moment, there is really only one last question left to ask.

Is It Worth It?

Kratos? Snake? Sackboy? Turismo? Blu-ray? 100-plus gigs of hard drive space? Well, I mean no offense, but like Shania Twain once sang, "that don't impress me much." Plus, as someone who already owns a 360 and Wii, it makes it an even tougher decision.

But, man, watching those gameplay videos makes me want to still run out and pick up the game. The Show is asking me to dig in a bit deeper so I can digitally dig into the box with Braun, Hanley or J-Ham. It is looking to me to just pitch in a few crisp hundreds so I can throw that 100-plus mph fastball with Zumaya.

There is no doubt that it is a difficult choice to make, but personally, I admit that if my laptop had not died on me recently, I would have made the leap. But alas, I suppose it just was not meant to be, at least not this year anyway.

And in the end, I suppose it will be a personal choice everyone has to make. But the fact that many people are even considering a sports game as a system seller during these hard times simply speaks volumes about The Show's quality.

So, sure, it is no Halo or Zelda, and Mark Teixeira or Miguel Cabrera may not be any real competition for Marcus Fenix or Niko Bellic. In the end, though, MLB 09: The Show has shown me that in its own unique way, it is indeed a killer app.


MLB '09: The Show Videos
Member Comments
# 61 Glenn33 @ 03/12/09 03:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrUrsus
In my opinion, MVP is one of the most overrated games. Not saying it isn't good, it was, but over time, it has gotten this "mythical" baseball status. Quite frankly, I liked High Heat 2005 (the one with Schilling on the cover) better. Sure, the graphics weren't as good, but you could really control rosters, and the game played great. If the graphics would have been good, people would be slobbering over that game still.
MLB 09 The Show blows MVP out of the water. Not even a competition in my opinion, but to each their own.
Co-sign BIG TIME!!!!
 
# 62 SBartlett @ 03/12/09 07:25 PM
BRYAN GREAT ARTICLE MAN!
 
# 63 Chip1010 @ 03/12/09 07:50 PM
There were several things about the PS3 that I was interested in -- Blu-ray, LittleBigPlanet, Metal Gear -- but I don't think I would have purchased one had it not been for baseball.

I was preparing to just take my lumps with 2K9 and just try to enjoy it, but after reading some of the reviews of both games and seeing The Show in action on an OS video, I said to hell with fiscal responsibility and made the jump. I haven't regretted it for a second.
 
# 64 punkologist @ 03/13/09 12:07 AM
exactly windu. I bought my PS3 for MLB 08 and I am glad I did.
I do enjoy Gran Turismo too, so it will be worth it when that comes out (when ever it eventually does!)
 
# 65 vick5 @ 03/13/09 12:13 AM
Just bought a 80 gb Ps3 and the show 09 today. Was upset it didn't come with any hd cables but I know the show will be worth it!
 
# 66 bobz99by @ 03/13/09 12:53 AM
I'm as a big a proponent of mlb the show as it gets...wrote a huge arse review of mlb 08 for psp on my blog...

but i'm not sure I can justify 300 dollars for a ps3 to play Mlb the show. Are all the graphics and sounds and bells and whistles reallly worth 300 bux. I mean isn't the core gamplay still the same whether its ps3, ps2, psp.

Recently, i played PES 6 (winning eleven) on my ps2 with a couple buddies and had as much fun as playing PES 2009 on my pc. At its core, the game is still similar.

I guess online play would be the one thing that ps3 has over the other two. I'm not sure though that i would utilize it that much. I mostly play road to the show.

Crysis blew me away with its graphics and I'm considering upgrading my comp to run it. But I'm not sure the graphics boost of psp to ps3 mlb is worth it. In some respects, psp road to the show is the most perfect iteration. Portable. Pick it up play a couple innings. Shut it off.
 
# 67 EnigmaNemesis @ 03/13/09 01:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bobz99by
I'm as a big a proponent of mlb the show as it gets...wrote a huge arse review of mlb 08 for psp on my blog...

but i'm not sure I can justify 300 dollars for a ps3 to play Mlb the show. Are all the graphics and sounds and bells and whistles reallly worth 300 bux. I mean isn't the core gamplay still the same whether its ps3, ps2, psp.

Recently, i played PES 6 (winning eleven) on my ps2 with a couple buddies and had as much fun as playing PES 2009 on my pc. At its core, the game is still similar.

I guess online play would be the one thing that ps3 has over the other two. I'm not sure though that i would utilize it that much. I mostly play road to the show.

Crysis blew me away with its graphics and I'm considering upgrading my comp to run it. But I'm not sure the graphics boost of psp to ps3 mlb is worth it. In some respects, psp road to the show is the most perfect iteration. Portable. Pick it up play a couple innings. Shut it off.
IMO spending $300 on the PS3 for this game, and many other games out there, is more worth it than a PC for a mediocre (gameplay wise) game like Crysis.

If you ever played it, you would know. The gameplay is much improved on the PS3 version.
 
# 68 erod550 @ 03/13/09 05:45 AM
It's why I own a PS3. Bought it for The Show 07 and Gran Turismo 5, which was disappointing compared to Forza 2. The only games I own for the PS3 are GT5 and The Show 07, 08, and 09, and I don't regret buying the system for a minute.
 
# 69 EnigmaNemesis @ 03/13/09 05:49 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by erod550
It's why I own a PS3. Bought it for The Show 07 and Gran Turismo 5, which was disappointing compared to Forza 2. The only games I own for the PS3 are GT5 and The Show 07, 08, and 09, and I don't regret buying the system for a minute.

To be fair, it isnt the "real" GT5. That is coming supposedly end of this year. It was a "prologue" to the real game.

The real game I am eagerly waiting for as well.
 
# 70 DiddyGotGrillz @ 03/13/09 12:07 PM
Did the exact same thing bro....traded in a lot of old 360 games, including a 6 day old copy of 2K9, and paid $330 out of pocket.

That $330 wasn't just for The Show and a PS3.........it was $330 to ensure that I would NEVER have to play another 2K Sports games ever again. That, to me, is $330 WELL spent.
 
# 71 DiddyGotGrillz @ 03/13/09 12:09 PM
You are absolutely right....No question. I camparing them against each other, I DO believe that The Show has MANY similar components to MVP....but just 10000 times better EVERYTHING, hence "on steroids" comment.
 
# 72 DiddyGotGrillz @ 03/13/09 12:12 PM
Coming from a guy that has 200 wrapped up in a PSP and game....hahaha.
 
# 73 Shadymamba @ 03/14/09 03:53 AM
its funny you write this article i was telling my friend today, i cant play 2k anymore man im buying a ps3 and the show..honest so for me at least yep its a system seller
 
# 74 SD2240 @ 03/14/09 11:25 AM
It's a system seller because i just bought a ps3 for the show last night. And I sure am glad i did. The show is the greatest sports game ever. I just imagine what it would be like to get an nfl game from this team. I had been trying to play 2k9 on the 360 but its just cutting it. i have wanted a blu ray player again for a while but the show is what finally got me moving!
 
# 75 hi-teck @ 03/14/09 02:12 PM
I would say MLB The Show is the best baseball game I've played (loved Bases Loaded for Nintendo back in the day), but I didn't get the PS3 just for that game. I think there will be other criteria people consider when making the decision, such as it doubling as a blu-ray player since HD-DVD is dead. At least people will take solace that so far, Sony has showed it will continue to put in quality for the MLB The Show franchise, as I've played 07, 08 and now 09.
 
# 76 whosgotcha @ 03/14/09 07:11 PM
MLB The Show 09 is an amazing baseball game. It is an amazing sports game. To me out of basketball, football and baseball video games it's the best sports game out by far. In terms of visuals, animations, graphics, and details it may be one of the best games out period. But.....its not a system seller because it's......baseball. And bestball videogames do not have the vast audience of the other game genres. This game is so amazing that if it were a generic football game with all the same phenomenal aspects it would be a system seller in the U.S.
 
# 77 Bigtonyclark @ 03/15/09 01:14 AM
Placed my order for my 80 GB PS3 today.

Estimated arrival date is the 24th, though.....
 
# 78 WhiteMan22 @ 03/15/09 10:36 PM
No, def not for just one game. If you are looking to sell your 360 to get the Show, i will not stop you. I can see you doing that for the blue-ray and the other games listed. But for any hardcore sports fan, you are making the most stupidest decision ever. If you only play sports game, the 360 is the best sysytem. Madden, NHL(both), NCAA Football, NBA 2K are all better games on the 360 then the PS3. The only good PS3 sport game is the Show and maybe Tiger Woods. If anyone wants to argue with me my last statement, then go f*** yourself cause you know I am right.
 
# 79 corpkid12 @ 03/15/09 11:06 PM
I made the leap and haven't regretted it. The show is the best sports game I have ever played! As a 360 owner, I passed on a baseball game in 08 and after seeing 2k9's reviews, I wasn't missing another year of baseball!
 
# 80 carseller14 @ 03/15/09 11:45 PM
Just bought a PS3 this weekend simply for The Show. I have been playing 2k since 06 and this year it was just unbearable to play. I had never played The Show until this weekend and until then, I did not realize just how bad MLB 2k9 sucked. The Show is absolutely unbelievable. I play more baseball games than anything so this is like a dream come true. My only regret is that I paid $60 for 2k9. Now if I could learn how to hit on the show I will be okay.
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.