Home
Feature Article
Top Five NCAA Football Games of All Time

With under a month to go until the NCAA Football 09 release, and with a demo that dropped yesterday, I figured it was the right time to list my top five NCAA Football video games of all time.

#5. NCAA '08 (Xbox 360)


I know I will take some heat for this, but I thought last year's game was solid. In other words, it was what the first installment on next-gen should have been in my eyes. Graphically it was a step up, and they tightened up the gameplay controls from the year before.

The new recruiting was also something that was interesting, although a bit tedious after a while. Nonetheless, offseason was fun to play overall and on the field resulted in some good times, especially post-patch. Once you could drop the balls in over the linebackers and in before the secondary the game played very well, and head-to-head was then more about play calling and execution rather than money plays.

#4. The Original, Bill Walsh’s College Football (Sega Genesis)

This game was literally the “granddaddy of ‘em all.” The first college football game didn’t have every D-1A team, let alone have real college names. BYU was Provo and Penn St. was State College, but still you got the point. The game was so much fun to play -- perfect for having friends over and playing all night with a couple of bottles of Mountain Dew to help your cause.

I remember running with the '88 Notre Dame team almost exclusively. Nobody was able to matchup with the option when Tony Rice was under center. His spin move was beastly, and people would just bounce off him. Basically once he got into the open field it was game over. Combine him with Rocket Ismail and a few other All-Americans that had great pro careers and you have an unstoppable team.

The game was ahead of its time in the gameplay department. And that's why what the game lacked in season mode it made up for with fun factor and replay value.

#3. College Football '96 (Sega Genesis)

Finally a season mode worth playing nonstop in the NCAA series. This game featured the pageantry and excitement of college football in all its mid-'90s 16-bit glory. The game played fast and smooth, and had real polls and teams, with your choice of a tournament or bowls to crown the winner at the end of a great season.

Running the option in this game was fun, and choosing your own playbook was a feature that helped the college football genre turn a page in history. This game was the first to feature the BCS and set the stage for what dynasty would become down the line.

#2. NCAA '99 (PS1)


One of the most fun head-to-head games I ever played. I remember teaching one of my best friends to play the series on this game. He rolled with Big Kat and the OSU Buckeyes as I usually took UCF with Daunte Culpepper or Indiana with freshman Antwaan Randle El. The most memorable moment I recall was throwing a pick with Daunte one time, and as my friend is running it back Culpepper is the last man to beat. I had the angle on him for the stop so rather than making a move my friend tries to run virtual Daunte over, and instead Daunte just lays him out, pre-Hit Stick.

This game also had a few neat futures, like a postseason all-star game in the Shrine Game. You could also play games in other stadiums; I remember playing dynasty games in Pitt Stadium as well as Three Rivers, something that blew my mind at the time.

#1. NCAA 2004 (PS2)


EA hit the jackpot with this game. Everything was closer to perfection than ever accomplished before in a football game. Online was stellar, and dynasty mode was epic as well.

Gameplay was tight and tended to roll towards the offensive side with a few money plays, but head-to-head was outstanding with one key stop or turnover usually deciding the outcome.

My favorite was running my Pitt Panthers dynasty and talking Larry Fitzgerald into staying his whole career. He won three straight Heisman Trophies and set every possible school and NCAA record for me. The guy was a beast!

Online was fun too. I lived in a big apartment in Pittsburgh and had two roommates and a girlfriend at Pitt at the time. I would get home from work late at night, as would my buddy. We would play online from 11 p.m. to 4 a.m. He would run the offense and I would put my defense down on anyone who tried to cheese us. It ended up being a lethal combo and provided many nights of fun.

On weekends we would go to the Pitt game and see Larry do his thing in person, and come back and have a party which usually led to a NCAA tournament (something the girlfriend never appreciated).

So that was a fun trip down memory lane. How would you guys rank your top five NCAA football games?

This article is also featured on Bleacher Report. Bleacher Report is where the sports bar meets the press box, the place for fan-journalists to create and critique high-quality sports analysis. Visit Bleacher Report for more video games news.


Member Comments
# 21 ODogg @ 06/20/08 07:38 PM
No love for NCAA "stone hands" 05?
 
# 22 N51_rob @ 06/20/08 07:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ODogg
No love for NCAA "stone hands" 05?
That game did so much right too. Just the drops were HORRIBLE
 
# 23 stoncold32 @ 06/20/08 07:51 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ODogg
No love for NCAA "stone hands" 05?
That game was so highly anticipated due to the tremendous '04 effort....and it was flat out terrible. I remember the mall in Norman being filled with people waiting to get a copy of this game. Mostly OU students and football players, people couldnt wait.
 
# 24 BSanders @ 06/20/08 08:23 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by mgoblue13
i think that ncaa 06 wa the best ncaa game ever

I agree with that... I still play 06 Madden and NCAA.
 
# 25 GetYaWeigtUp @ 06/20/08 09:59 PM
Here's my list. The running game and create-a-school made 03 the best for me. I loved the heck out of 07 also, it was better then 08. And 99 was classic. Im onthe 04 bandwaggon although I dont remember much about it. 97 was a monster for me and my buds. The way you could reverse field with ease and make huge runs non-stop, that was classic. We played that game all night!

1) 03
2) 07
3) 99 (PS1)
4) 04
5) 97 (PS1)
 
# 26 tehova @ 06/20/08 10:24 PM
College Football 96 is 1a with NCAA 2004 because I made my college choice based on the fun I had with East Carolina in the game.
 
# 27 texbuk84 @ 06/21/08 12:38 AM
ncaa 04 was the greatest football game ever made(overall wise). this game had the best recruiting system to date( ireally enjoyed that), and the online multiplayer was bananas. this game totally rocked.
 
# 28 Spectre @ 06/21/08 01:00 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jwil5050
ncaa 04 was the greatest football game ever made(overall wise). this game had the best recruiting system to date( ireally enjoyed that), and the online multiplayer was bananas. this game totally rocked.
No doubt- 2004 is, by far, the best in the series to this point. It was a phenomenal game. I won't agree with the best football game comment though

There are only two games that I have purchased that I instantly wanted my money back after playing the game:

NCAA 2005 with the ridiculous stuttering on the Xbox and MLB 2K6. The NCAA series for me went downhill bad after 2004.
 
# 29 bad_philanthropy @ 06/21/08 01:12 AM
My question for any of the developers stalking around here is how did so much go so wrong for 2005 after 2004. I mean it was uncanny how the game went from best to worst.
 
# 30 OMT @ 06/21/08 02:29 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by BSherrod
Dude, I love having you guys on the board and I have gotten a chance to sink a lot of time into the game. For 2004 to be topped, in my opinion, the presentation needs a big bump. Nothing beats the Notre Dame intro (Whom I hate) or Miami coming out of the smoke. Those same animations with new models and the player spotlights and you might have a winner.
Notre Dame was the only real entrance. The others were generic. Did you watch it every time? Just wondering.
 
# 31 OMT @ 06/21/08 02:36 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by smurface
Never knew in '99 you could play in Three Rivers and Pitt Stadium..that game was the best though. I loved recruiting in that game, and if i remember correct Louisiana Tech was always the powerhouse if you simmed 5 to 10 seasons


This is why I love the hardcore gamers! The game was the best and LA Tech would be a power house in year 7.

Now, if LA Tech were to be a powerhouse in year 7 on NCAA 09, we'd get GRILLED on this board!
 
# 32 OMT @ 06/21/08 02:39 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sausage

**I love 04 and 06 the most** I believe they took away some presentation in 06 that bothered me, specifically team entrances.
Yes. Due to memory reasons the entrances had to be killed in favor of ESPN Gameday/Virtual Corso (as we called it).
 
# 33 OMT @ 06/21/08 02:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Soldier
08 and 2005 were absolutely awful. 07 was solid, but way too stripped down.
I agree 05 was bad.

07 was stripped down? You're talking about the Next Gen (Xbox 360) version right? Keep in mind it was a totally new game versus another iteration on the game that started in 2002.

08 I don't think was awful. At final, I thought it was pretty good.... but after playing it for a while I changed my mind. We made huge strides there (video highlights, deep recruiting, 60 fps on xbox), but it just didn't "come together" to make it a great game.
 
# 34 OMT @ 06/21/08 02:51 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bad_philanthropy
My question for any of the developers stalking around here is how did so much go so wrong for 2005 after 2004. I mean it was uncanny how the game went from best to worst.
Looks like I'm on a roll in this thread so I'll post one more before going to bed!

My answer? I don't know. Sorry. Can't say much other than that. The feature set was sweet (Home field advantage, sanctions), but I guess a lot of stuff went wrong and things got fixed poorly at the last minute.

I wasn't that involved at the time, so I'm just speculating based on my experience. I also didn't play it much after launch because of the drops.
 
# 35 bling1202 @ 06/21/08 03:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OMT
1. NCAA 09
2. NCAA 04
3. NCAA 03
4. NCAA 08
5. NCAA 06

That's my personal list.
sweet baby jesus, better than 04?

My list
1. 04
2. 06
3. 03
4. 05
5. 09 - haven't played enough to rank higher
 
# 36 Moojenowski @ 06/21/08 06:08 AM
I can't believe 06 for xbox isn't getting more love! I thought that was the best one ever, with 08 close behind it, and 09 (hopefully) ahead of it.

1. NCAA 06 (Xbox)
2. NCAA 08 (Xbox)
3. NCAA 04 (Xbox)
4. Gamebreaker 99 (PS1)
5. College Football 96 (Sega)

I was dominant in 96, but my dad was better lol. I got a sega for my birthday that year, and my dad bought it well in advance and opened it right away and would play NCAA while I was sleeping. He beat me up until High School in any football game, it was sweet having a gamer dad.

NCAA 06's running game was awesome, and I play with Minnesota, so Lawrence "Kool-Aid Man" Maroney would tear up the turf. My friend and I would sit and run practice with the Gophs against the Gators, put the ball at the 1 yard line and see who could go the distance running dive out of ace big,

Anyone know if they put random play in practice this year? That feature would keep me busy for hours!

Hopefully 09 is a new number 1.
 
# 37 blkprince04 @ 06/21/08 08:55 AM
for me its : ncaa03 xbox , ncaa 99 ps1 , ncaa04 xbox......99 is a classic for the ps1 so i had to put it on my list... 09 is to be determined...
 
# 38 FlyingFinn @ 06/21/08 12:06 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OMT
Notre Dame was the only real entrance. The others were generic. Did you watch it every time? Just wondering.
I did. I still watch every pre-game,halftime and post game along with the weekly wrap up in my NFL 2k5 franchise and this is 1000's of games later.
 
# 39 jmood88 @ 06/21/08 12:11 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by OMT
NCAA 2004 was better than NFL 2k5!
No it wasn't.
 
# 40 umd @ 06/21/08 12:13 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by jmood88
No it wasn't.
Yeah it was. heh.

They were all pretty good on PS2 minus the horrendous 05. Man was that game a huuuuge letdown. 06 was a pretty good game especially I think because 05 was just so terrible.

'07 and '08 were both pretty mediocre for 360. '07 was understandable because it was the first try. '08 the CPU turnover AI was a huge replay gamekiller for me (even post patch) - similar to the drop problem in 05.

The old school PS1 days - NCAA strategies we used to pass the memory card save around.

Of course Bill Walsh is the college football version of Tecmo Bowl. I used to have this huge spiral notebook and make my own seasons and keep my own team stats. That was in middle school.
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.