Home
Feature Article
Fixing the March Madness Series

This past college basketball season brought a championship to Kansas, but also left a reigning champion in the dust. The College Hoops series is no more, and that loss leaves gamers with a lone college basketball game: March Madness. The struggling series now has the responsibility of catering to the college basketball crowd and hopefully providing for those people.

Even dating back to the last generation of systems the March Madness series has definitely not been up to the level of the competition that has been presented. So hoping for a stellar outing next season may be asking for a lot, but why not hope for the best?

I will be presenting five ideas in the form of an improvement/wishlist that I would like to see in this series.

Two notes:
*I have played this game after the patch and with the downloadable bracket
*These are in no specific order


Fix The Robotic Animations

This is one of my biggest issues with the game. The game looks fine at a standstill, but the second the players start moving the awkward motions cause the action to fall apart. Simply put, the way the players move take away from any realism that is trying to be achieved whether -- whether it is the crossover animations that don't look smooth, or the way the players rebound where they jump straight up in the air hoping for the ball to warp to their hands. Overall, the animations are just sluggish in general no matter what is going on, and this fault needs to be fixed completely so March Madness can hopefully become a college basketball game that the sport deserves.

Make The Game Play Faster

When I first bought the game and turned it on for my yearly march madness fix during the actual tournament, I found myself fiddling with the gameplay sliders right away. Out of the box, the game seemed to move so slow no matter whom I was controlling. It did not matter whether I was Texas or CS Fullerton, they both moved and played the same.

Also, fast breaks seemed nonexistent as the opponent would easily catch up because there was no “fast” in the fast break. Basketball is a fast game and this needs to be improved in order to warrant a look next year.

Make The Game More Authentic

With College Hoops now being a series of the past we only have one place to turn for the authentic college basketball experience, but sadly March Madness did not have very much authenticity last year. The biggest issues are the lack of authentic stadiums and schedules in the dynasty mode. Both of these need to be addressed to add to the overall feel of college basketball and these should be non-issues seeing as how we are in the "next-generation" of systems.

What frustrates me about the lack of stadiums is the fact that in the '08 version of March Madness, the producers had a vote for which stadium they would include in the downloadable NCAA bracket pack. A vote? Are you kidding me? Why can't the producers just add all of those stadiums in the pack? Is that what this series has come to? Maybe next year people will vote for the stadium I want (OK so maybe that complaint is a little on the sour grapes side)...

Roster Share

Yes, I am aware of the EA Locker and it is decent. The main problem is having to be friends with the person before you can look in their locker. It just adds an unnecessary step and may create a hassle for some people as the friends list can only hold so many people. The producers should take a page from the College Hoops series and have a Roster Share-like option for people. This was such a great innovation by 2K which enabled rosters to be posted online in-game, and anyone could pull a roster up and download it to his or her hard drive. Genius.

Fix The A.I.

One last issue I want to touch upon has to deal with instances of the A.I. Sometimes in the game, the A.I. will show flashes of brilliance making a great give-and-go or a great post play to their big man. But in other cases, the A.I. can be just dumb and pointless. There are instances on fast breaks for example, where the A.I. opponent will catch up and force a 2-on-1, but once he gets there he does nothing.

Other instances include the opponent stealing passes that they had no business stealing, and the ridiculous amount of times the A.I. tries to draw charging fouls.

***

Were there things that were done right with this game? Absolutely, the post-game was brilliant and the dynasty mode was great in spite of the schedules. This game shows promise, but promise is not what we need, we need results.


NCAA Basketball 09 Videos
Member Comments
# 21 ehh @ 06/03/08 06:23 PM
I probably won't have to worry about MM09 since I sold my 360 and don't plan on buying another one for the foreseeable future, but I want there to be a good college game on the market each year.

There are a lot of issues that need fixing with this series starting first and foremost with the game play. I hate to say it but MM08 might be in the same boat as 2K baseball in terms of needing to ditch the engine and build from scratch.

When I played MM08 it looked like the animations were from a PS2/Xbox game, this is another area that desperately needs fixing. Everything from player movements to the nets after a swish needs to be upgraded.

In terms of dynasty mode, MM has a long way to go. Real schedules have been beaten to death but can't be understated. The recruiting process needs to be beefed up and I wish EA would just sit down with a copy of CH2K8 and copy it 100%.

Another big thing is the user/menu interface from everything to starting an exhibition to creating/editing a player. The edit-player feature and roster editing was brutally bad and slow in MM08. I love editing players/rosters but it was almost an unbearable task this year. It's the same problem in NCAA Football so I wouldn't hold my breath for this to be fixed.

The rosters need to be much more accurate, both current and classic rosters. As a die-hard UConn fan, I could hardly identify a single player on the all-time UConn squad. 1993 Michigan had Jimmy King and Chris Webber as the same ranking I believe.

Remember the big jump that CH made from 2K4 to 2K5? It felt, looked and played like a new engine. That's the type of change MM needs to make, this game needs a whole new feel.
 
# 22 BJNT @ 06/04/08 06:34 PM
As long as they bring back the option to export players to NBA Live like they did with March Madness 04 and Live 04. I will definately take a look at March Madness 09. That's the main reason why I've chosen College Hoops over March Madness. I love being able to watch a guy go from high school all-american, to college superstar, and then see what he can do in the NBA. March Madness brings this back I'm in.
 
# 23 radiohead @ 06/05/08 12:07 PM
Behindshadows2,

i'll cede your point that a lot of people who did not play march madness 08 are simply "hatin" and not providing any constructive criticism which "may" help fix mm.

but to be fair, the reason why many of those guys didn't play march madness 08 is because of how bad the game has historically been. in other words, i think it's hard to find a large community to draw constructive criticism from because MM as alienated so many gamers over the years.


i've always thought that mm had superior atmosphere and presentation AND that mm has always had potential to be much better than choops. but, the finished product always feels like a rudderless boat.

it's good to know that there is a new dev. team working on mm. that fact alone will put mm on my radar. but honestly, i'm not holding my breath.

like you said, it's time for results.
 
# 24 sixfootjew @ 09/10/08 02:10 PM
LEGACY MODE LIKE 2k... nothing is tighter than starting with a butt cheeks squad and earning other coaching jobs after 2 seasons, or making that tm into a contender..
 
# 25 mac022393 @ 09/27/08 06:30 PM
All u need to make the game better is to allow the users to down load the draft classes from March Madness to Live as in NCAA Football and Madden.
 
# 26 Tomba @ 09/27/08 08:04 PM
I think it is very important to note the gameplay nad game mode improvements the games made via my recap thread. There really shouldn't be any negativity around this title as it's been vastly improved over NCAA 08 for starters. I can not stress enough that EA have made strides with NCAA 09. Again, it's a improvement over the upcoming NBA Live 09 as well.
 
# 27 Heelfan71 @ 09/28/08 11:59 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Behindshadows
Again another pointless post!

Again, you want to dispute me, but you've never played the game! And there is no dynasty on the demo. So again your points aren't valid or even worth the convo.


!

I played both and I dispute your claim. CH Dynasty > MM Dynasty
 
# 28 Behindshadows @ 09/28/08 02:37 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Heelfan71
I played both and I dispute your claim. CH Dynasty > MM Dynasty
Why are you opening up old wounds?

I'm done with this debate and have moved on to NCAA Basketball 09. Waiting the release and waiting to see some gameplay. I'm sure it will be what all College Basketball fans will enjoy.

MM08 wasn't bad, but hopefully NCAA 09 will be a great improvement over all the things that plagued MM08 last season.

Can't wait...

And got Tarheels.... Alumni
 
# 29 Tomba @ 09/28/08 04:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Behindshadows
Why are you opening up old wounds?

I'm done with this debate and have moved on to NCAA Basketball 09. Waiting the release and waiting to see some gameplay. I'm sure it will be what all College Basketball fans will enjoy.

MM08 wasn't bad, but hopefully NCAA 09 will be a great improvement over all the things that plagued MM08 last season.

Can't wait...

And got Tarheels.... Alumni

Many of the things plaguing last years NCAA 08 are gone largely in part to it now using the NBA Live 09 engine as a base and then improving on it to make it feel more like College basketball.
 
# 30 Heelfan71 @ 09/28/08 07:35 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Behindshadows
Why are you opening up old wounds?

I'm done with this debate and have moved on to NCAA Basketball 09. Waiting the release and waiting to see some gameplay. I'm sure it will be what all College Basketball fans will enjoy.

MM08 wasn't bad, but hopefully NCAA 09 will be a great improvement over all the things that plagued MM08 last season.

Can't wait...

And got Tarheels.... Alumni

I hope you are right.
 

« Previous 12Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.