I think he wasn't destroyed. I think they might have been too good to him considering he hasn't played in two years. All in all it seems fair. The haters don't get their way and he is below and 50 and the lovers don't get their way and he's a 90+.

EA didn't destroy him. They got him about right.

^ LMAO


I think the rating is perfect.

The question wasn't should the NFL have let him back in or not. And I can't say I disagree that maybe he shouldn't have, but they did allow Leonard Little back after he killed woman in a DUI and are going to allow Dropsworth back in after he suspended for killing a man in a DUI.

Little should be gone. Not only did he kill that woman, he has since gotten another DUI so has proven to not learn his lesson. To me, if these two who have killed humans are allowed back in the NFL, then Vick should get his second chance.

Personally none of them should be in the NFL anymore, but that's just me. Anyway, that was the topic. Topic was if the rating was fair. I still think it was.

The rating is fine...especially since it can improve once we see what he is capable of doing at this point....and @twiztiddarkangelman....get a life.

I think his rating is realistic still has speed and arm strength and was never known for accuracy. He deserves a second chance to make a living and play in the NFL. Hey some people work at walmart it just so happens that his job is in the NFL. I'll tell you what they did murder was his skin color it looks too light on the game.

I think it's fine for the fact that he hasn't played in 2yrs and they have NOTHING current to go on in terms of his skills and gameplay.

twitz and thescoop - Like I've said before to others talking that jazz; YOU commit a crime, serve your time, then try to straighten up, fly right and support yourself and/or family and see how much yang you're talking then. MANY of ex-convicts cannot even get a chance to earn a decent living and guess what they end up doing? Committing crimes again because society won't give them a chance. It's a tough deal and yes it could be said that they shouldn't have done what they've done but sometimes it's just NOT as black and white as it seems plus that's not the Vick situation.

Vick is extremely lucky to be in the NFL where second chances ARE given and make MILLIONS while at it. What he did was heinous, yes, but to say he shouldn't be given another chance especially if he did not MURDER a human (Little's issue is a diff and I definitely believe he should NOT have been allowed to play, anymore, after the second offense but Stallworth's situation, I believe, is more reinstateable).
If Vick gets caught doing it again, ok, bye-bye Vick but to say he does not belong back in the NFL now is ridiculous. Think about what I'm saying here.

Trey, how about no....i'm not going to commit a crime. So that's not something i can even relate to because I'm smart enough to not do it. And if I was making millions in the NFL I'd be flying straight because I wouldn't want to risk loosing it.

I really don't think we should focus anymore time away from the topic at hand though, but I had to respond since you addressed me.

it is fair due to not knowing how well he will do this year not sayin he will do bad but lets just see wat happens. In way its kinda hard to rate sum1 who hasnt played for 2 years just my opinion.

its fair but he should be faster

Based on his time spent away and what he did last time he was the field, yeah it's fair. And to the guy crying about the poor innocent animals...get off the booboo. If he's got to sit in jail, then everyone who does their hunting thing with their john deere hat, and high powered rifle as needs to do the same. everybody's talking fair...fair is fair

What's funny is all the people taking the eagles and making him the QB trying to scramble and throwing INT's to me. Then realizing that McNabb is the better QB (can't believe how dumb people are) but have put themselves to far into the hole to win. Play McNabb he is a much better QB scrambling with Vick for big yards is so easy to stop.

I love having the option of just using Vick with my Eagles he's turning more and more into a weapon X for me. I rock out with McNabb and only use Vick 8-10 plays a game but he always comes up big for me.

I try slip him in the game before whoever I'm playing realizes it and at moments where you would use a player with his skill set i.e goal line, certain rollouts with the option to run or pass and easy pass plays comebacks, screens, slants.

He's on my team and I'm gonna take advantage of his skills but he will throw some picks if you use him incorrectly or as you every down QB. People who play with my Eagles just to be able to run or pass with Vick are cheesers and I hope they get shut down.