Home
MLB 15 The Show News Post


Winning the Cy Young award is the most coveted accolade a pitcher could strive for. Clayton Kershaw, the 2014 N.L. winner, sports a 99 as you would expect from the "best." But what about the A.L. Cy Young award winner Corey Kluber? In MLB 14 The Show, Kluber's rating was a 76. His rating this year got a generous bump to a 90. While this is a great rating, you have to ask yourself if the 90 rating is high enough.

Read More - MLB 15 The Show: How Winning The Cy Young Affects Your Rating

Game: MLB 15 The ShowReader Score: 9/10 - Vote Now
Platform: PS Vita / PS3 / PS4Votes for game: 31 - View All
MLB 15 The Show Videos
Member Comments
# 21 WaitTilNextYear @ 03/21/15 04:40 PM
This game is broken and unplayable until Kluber gets that 99 OVR; basically it's just a port of '14 or a roster update at best.*




*Note that this is just me trying to fit all of everyone's favorite buzz words into the same sentence and does not reflect my actual opinion on the matter.
 
# 22 Ghost Of The Year @ 03/21/15 04:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by NYC22
" Is that really fair to the supposed “best” pitcher in the American League?" LMAO!
Best pitcher in the AL in 2014, that's debatable, though I can go with it.
Best pitcher in the AL, no qualifier? I'm going with King Felix #1
#2 David Price
#3 Chris Sale
#4 Kluber
#5 Yu Darvish (when healthy, lol there's a qualifier after all)

Here;s another qualifier: If Max Scherzer was still a Tiger, then I'd have him 3rd or 4th.
Verlander could easily have been in my top 5.
 
# 23 HozAndMoose @ 03/21/15 05:12 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ghost Of The Year
Best pitcher in the AL in 2014, that's debatable, though I can go with it.
Best pitcher in the AL, no qualifier? I'm going with King Felix #1
#2 David Price
#3 Chris Sale
#4 Kluber
#5 Yu Darvish (when healthy, lol there's a qualifier after all)

Here;s another qualifier: If Max Scherzer was still a Tiger, then I'd have him 3rd or 4th.
Verlander could easily have been in my top 5.
You list officially became invalid after mentioning Verlander at all.

Last 3 years he is 18th in ERA, 8th in FIP, 13th in K/9, 36th in BB/9, 7th in HR/9, The only stat that says he should be top 5 is WAR and thats just because he had 7 in 2012. His 3.99 ERA the last 2 years is 32nd among qualified pitchers. He was top(bottom) 5 in something last year though. 5th worst ERA.
 
# 24 Ghost Of The Year @ 03/21/15 05:18 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HozAndMoose
You list officially became invalid after mentioning Verlander at all.

Yeah, he's had a rough couple years, but I'm hoping he's ready for a comeback this year.
 
# 25 HozAndMoose @ 03/21/15 05:26 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ghost Of The Year

Yeah, he's had a rough couple years, but I'm hoping he's ready for a comeback this year.
Yeah well I hope his arm falls off.
 
# 26 tnacrimson @ 03/21/15 06:10 PM
really depends because who are the 10 rated above him i assume are king felix herndez, kershaw, madison bum(should recive just as generas as of a boost),chris sale(maybe),max sherezer, david price, john lester(?),wanio, wanna say johnny cueto, and i dont know a tenth thats probley some good company all of which have been good pitchers in the past and have won and or came in second in cy voting so 90 is decent ecspilly for a jump the show series isnt one of those games that likes to give people giant leaps in rating so that was generous
 
# 27 @legendm0de @ 03/26/15 05:02 PM
This just begs the question, Why is baseball of all sports games converting to this numerical rating crap in the first place. We shouldn't be doing this argument over Kluber imo, I just want to play not decipher this overall rating formula which can change month to month nearly.
 
# 28 Dynasty Legend 99 @ 04/02/15 08:03 PM
I honestly felt this was an honest rating of Kluber. One more year of top-tier pitching and he will be 93-95 but I don't know if he exceeds that.
 
# 29 HustlinOwl @ 05/12/15 12:41 PM
lmao 90 is apparently too high, dude has been terrible this year

 
# 30 Knight165 @ 05/12/15 01:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by HustlinOwl
lmao 90 is apparently too high, dude has been terrible this year

Shhh...don't bring this up the performance progression thread.
Guys are ready to commit suicide in there because Mike Trout and others didn't propel into the galaxy after good years.

M.K.
Knight165
 
# 31 HozAndMoose @ 05/14/15 11:56 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rudoffs
I'm sorry, you were saying?
Talk to me when he does good a couple games in a row.
 
# 32 Dolenz @ 05/14/15 12:01 PM
He was certainly stellar last night and made the Cardinals look really, really bad but just like it takes more than one year to arrive at a rating in this game it also takes more than one game to convince us that he is back to his Cy Young form.
 
# 33 cardinalbird5 @ 05/14/15 12:11 PM
His metrics are good. It doesnt help getting no run support and having a terrible defense behind him.
 
# 34 Will I Am @ 05/14/15 12:18 PM
Why did the Indians pull Kluber when he had a chance at history? He had only thrown 115 pitches I think.
 
# 35 HustlinOwl @ 05/14/15 12:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rudoffs
his first 3 games of the season were good. we scored 0 and 2 runs in two of his losses and then blew the save for him in the other game.

While he pitched poorly in his next 4 games, we scored 0, 2, 2, and 3 runs for him in those games before he left.

Last night we scored 2 again.
plus 5.00 ERA prior to last night is not good
 
# 36 cardinalbird5 @ 05/14/15 12:21 PM
ERA doesnt mean much when you got the Indians defense behind you.

His lob pct and babip will regress to the mean and his ERA will be fine.
 
# 37 HustlinOwl @ 05/14/15 12:25 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by cardinalbird7
ERA doesnt mean much when you got the Indians defense behind you.

His lob pct and babip will regress to the mean and his ERA will be fine.
same terrible defense last year?
 
# 38 Ghost Of The Year @ 05/23/15 09:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by rudoffs
This was a fun thread for his detractors for a few weeks. That's over now
Baseball's a funny game, full of streaks & slumps. Wouldn;t be much of a reach for someone to trollbump the thread & reignite the flame.
 
# 39 rinngjj @ 05/24/15 01:19 PM
That gif. made it really tough to read the article, yikes.
 

« Previous 12Next »

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.