News Post

Second Ever Greatest Sports Game of All Time Tournament -- Nominations Thread

09:48 PM - February 15, 2012 by RaychelSnr

Back in 2008, we ran a 64 game tournament to decide the greatest sports game ever.

In our tournament back in 2008, NFL 2K5 dominated College Hoops 2K8 in the championship to capture the crown over 63 other sports games which were nominated by you and seeded by our staff.

Since 2008, we have seen many new great competitors enter the race. NBA 2K11, NHL 10, FIFA Soccer 10, MLB: The Show (pick a year), Forza Motorsport 4, WWE '12, Out of Park Baseball X, Trials Evolution are among many other likely newcomers into the bracket.

Before we seed the bracket, we are now taking nominations for seeding consideration. Please nominate all of the games you'd like to see in the bracket, games with more mentions in the thread will obviously get stronger consideration to be included in the 68 team bracket.

Nominations will be taken until we seed the brackets. Seeding will be announced on February 29, 2012. Match-ups will be announced March 1, 2012. Voting will begin to start crowning the champ on March 11, 2012.

So what are you waiting for? Start nominating your favorite sports games of all time!!

Member Comments

# 101 Bonee @ 02/16/12 01:19 PM

Summer Games (C64 / Rushware)
Pro Evolution Soccer 6 (PC / Konami)
Madden 2k8 (PC / EA)
FIFA 12 (PS3 / EA)

# 102 OGKing @ 02/16/12 01:26 PM

NBA 2k11
CH2k8

# 103 SDwinder @ 02/16/12 02:21 PM

Earl Weaver Baseball (Amiga)
Hardball (C64)
Oldtime Baseball (PC)
High Heat Baseball 2002 PC
MVP Baseball 2005 with mods PC
The Show 12 PS3
NCAA 12 Football 360
NBA 2K12 360
Forza 4 360
Need For Speed Hot Pursuit PS3
Top Spin 4 360

# 104 waltsundberg @ 02/16/12 02:29 PM

Forza 4
MLB the Show 10
NHL 2K 10
Madden 10

# 105 SDwinder @ 02/16/12 02:52 PM

Forgot a couple.

World Series Baseball 94 (Genesis)
First Madden on Genesis 1991???
NHL 94 Genesis

# 106 SDwinder @ 02/16/12 02:55 PM

Need For Speed Porsche Unleashed (PC)

# 107 sportyguyfl31 @ 02/16/12 02:55 PM

Madden 05, MLB The Show 11, NCAA 06, NHL 94, NCAA 12, NBA2K8

# 108 mWolfe @ 02/16/12 03:29 PM

1. Tecmo Super Bowl
2. 10 Yard Fight (Arcade)
3. NFL 2k5
4. Ch2k8
5.Madden 04(pc)
6.NCAA 06
7.NFL Hard Yardage (Arcade)
8. Smackdown vs Raw 06( General Manager Mode was always way better than story mode IMO)

# 109 Jamake1005 @ 02/16/12 03:44 PM

NFL 2k5, Nba 2k11, and MLB The Show 11

# 110 jscand @ 02/16/12 03:47 PM

MLB11 the Show
MVP 05 (PC)
Madden 04
Smackdown Here Comes the Pain
NHL 94
Tecmo Super Bowl

# 111 blkrptnt819 @ 02/16/12 03:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by murph17


	forgot one...MARIO GOLF

I was gonna say Mario Kart but I didn't think that counted but Super Mario Kart was incredible.

# 112 blkrptnt819 @ 02/16/12 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by peigone


	Why even call this the "greatest ever"? If this poll is going to take place every 3-4 years, just call it the "greatest ever until a few months down the road when the fickle crowd changes their minds." What a world we live in, oy vey. 15 minutes of fame, 10 second sound bytes, what have you done for me lately, etc. and so forth. That or it must be a very slow month at OS, lol.

And here goes the party pooper

# 113 Sheamazin @ 02/16/12 03:59 PM

MLB the Show '11
Madden '04
NCAA '10
UFC Undisputed 3
WWE No Mercy

# 114 OG_McNabb @ 02/16/12 04:02 PM

Super Tecmo Bowl
NBA 2k11
Tecmo Bowl
NCAA 2004

# 115 matt8204 @ 02/16/12 04:17 PM

NHL '94
MVP Baseball 2005
NBA Live '95
Madden 2005

# 116 disguyman @ 02/16/12 04:28 PM

NBA 2K11, MLB 09 The Show, Mario Tennis N64, Punch Out, Tecmo Super Bowl, Mario Kart N64, NBA JAM SNES, NBA Live 95, Fight Night Round 4, WWF No Mercy N64, Gran Turismo 2, and of course Double Dribble on the NES.

# 117 xboxman41 @ 02/16/12 04:45 PM

NFL 2K5
NBA 2K11
Fight NIGHT CHAMPIONSHIP
MADDEN what year???????? NEVER....HMM.......

# 118 smithdynasty @ 02/16/12 05:24 PM

COLLEGE HOOPS 2k8

# 119 dxdude2004 @ 02/16/12 06:35 PM

I think NCAA Football 12 should get a nice #12 seed. :P LOL Just my opnion.

# 120 kujoking7 @ 02/16/12 06:57 PM

gotta get MVP 2005 in there, that and MLB 11 The Show have to be the best baseball games ever made.

« Previous 1 2 3 4 567 8 9 10 11 12 Next »

More Links

Second Ever Greatest Sports Game of All Time Tournament -- Nominations Thread