jmik58's Blog
Top Sports News for Wednesday, August 28, 2013
QOTD: Are low blocks too dangerous or should defenders stop complaining?
- Prelude to panic mode? The Pirates stir up their roster with a trade as the NL Central gets tighter -- Cards take over first place.
- RGIII says he's fully recovered and sources with the team say he'll start in Monday night's opener.
- Vikings players are livid over a "legal" block that injured the knee of star DT Kevin Williams.
- A few decades later and Joe Namath hasn't shied away from bold statements or criticism to stir the organization.
- Green Bay faces a tough early-season schedule and the loss of Dujuan Harris in the secondary puts more pressure on the Packers offense.
- Rolling Stone alleges that Aaron Hernandez was a big-time user of PCP.
- Check out all of the new uniforms for the 2013 college football season.
- Redskins plan to play Pat White the entire preseason finale at QB.
- Davis-Cabrera homerun battle more exciting than McGwire-Sosa chase from '98?
- San Fran's Pence and Sandoval may have the best handshake in sports history.
# 1
GlennN @ Aug 28
My short answer is "no," but the longer answer is if they insist on protecting "defenseless players," a concept I find completely foreign to a sport like football, then, for consistency, how could they not outlaw such hits? Williams was every bit as defenseless as a receiver going up for a ball - either both are protected, or (in my preference) neither. I miss the days of a safety actually being able to separate a receiver from a ball and going over the middle being dangerous. The new NFL is way, way less fun to watch.
# 3
criscarter @ Aug 28
Low blocks like that, absolutely. I'm a bit biased, but that is a senseless and awful block.
# 4
jmik58 @ Aug 28
I'm more of a defensive minded person from the playing and coaching days so I do have some bias on this, however ... I don't like low blocks for a couple reasons beyond injuries.
One is the fact that football is a game of skill and a successful block should depend on "ability". A cut block takes minimal skill. Also, there is little that a defender can do to equalize the playing field. For example, pass interference or holding can be called both ways. Most things "physical" about the game of football keep a close balance between offense and defense -- except for low blocks. What advantage does the defense have on the offense, or what can they do to counteract the impact of a cut block? I've yet to find the answer.
The injury concerns are self-explanatory. I wonder if the NFL would crack down on low blocks if they were facing a huge lawsuit related to them? Fortunately, you have a greater chance of successful surgery to repair a knee unlike an injury to the brain. But unfortunately, that means low blocks will likely stay around.
One is the fact that football is a game of skill and a successful block should depend on "ability". A cut block takes minimal skill. Also, there is little that a defender can do to equalize the playing field. For example, pass interference or holding can be called both ways. Most things "physical" about the game of football keep a close balance between offense and defense -- except for low blocks. What advantage does the defense have on the offense, or what can they do to counteract the impact of a cut block? I've yet to find the answer.
The injury concerns are self-explanatory. I wonder if the NFL would crack down on low blocks if they were facing a huge lawsuit related to them? Fortunately, you have a greater chance of successful surgery to repair a knee unlike an injury to the brain. But unfortunately, that means low blocks will likely stay around.
jmik58
42
jmik58's Blog Categories
jmik58's PSN Gamercard
jmik58's Screenshots (0)
jmik58 does not have any albums to display.
More
jmik58's Friends
Recent Visitors
The last 10 visitor(s) to this Arena were:
jmik58's Arena has had 1,418,131 visits
- bgordon0102
- Biglott
- Lewisf33
- Magist
- mastershake88
- maxodds
- NewNapkin
- protomemnon
- squashed377
- tical2399
jmik58's Arena has had 1,418,131 visits