What’s more fun player Chise or regular chise

[Flash03]

So I want to do one or other. What’s more fun player Chise where u choose a position or total control chise where u control the whole team with trades so on. I am getting Hall if fame edition on Xbox one

[JayCutlersCig]

For me, Player. If you wanna pretend you’re an NFL player, it’s the way to go, for obvious reasons. Just be prepared for amazingly stupid player AI and a messed up challenge system, unless they fixed it for 19.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[beastmode2013]

Hopefully player mode will be fun for non qbs this time

[JayCutlersCig]

Quote: Originally Posted by beastmode2013

Hopefully player mode will be fun for non qbs this time

Agreed. Route running in 18 is absolutely broken; get pushed or sucked into a holding animation, and lose all control of your player.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[ThePwnStar49]

I'd much rather take control of a full team. Unless Madden makes a my player like NBA2K with a storyline(one where i can create my own guy) then the single player chise gets boring after game 3

[warren123]

Easily full team. There just isn't enough substance IMO for using a player like there used to be. Not much to do outside of just playing games.

[joet6683]

I always like to start one as a player, usually MLB and play that until I find issues that are difficult to deal with. I love playing as an MLB this year with RPM, I am able to get a significant amount of tackles. Years past it was always around 5 or so combined, now i can get 10-15 combined solo and assisted.

Here are the issues with it this year:
-Some tackle goals are solo tackle and others are total tackle, but no wording to let you know which is which. It is easy enough to figure out, but it should be more clear.

-Boundary/rule issues. A receiver ran out the back of the end zone and caught a td. Even if they ignored the illegal touch rule, he never even established both feet in bounds, one was actually out when it was caught. No booth review.

-A receiver caught a td, but 2nd foot stepped out and the ball popped out. Should have been incomplete, at the very least OB. They did call a booth review but the TD upheld.

-sliders dont seem to work the same in player mode. I use 70 run block, 35 tackle, 0 speed differential, 70 fatigue. Players sub out, CPU and I can run in play now and team franchise. In player franchise players never get tired or sub out. The cpu never has a backup rb in other than the formation sub stuff. My teams fatigue on defense stays green. CPU still absolutely cannot run at all even though they can be very successful in the other modes.

-supersim - my team never uses a backup running back. starting rb, fb, and qb are the only players on the team with carries. my starting rb has about 60 more carries than the 2nd carry leader in the league 11 games in. They drive down the field but at the end of the half if they dont get to 4th down they wont kick a field goal, the time just runs out on a running play. That cost me a game when they didnt kick a winning fg at the end of the game.

[kcchiefs1984]

Create your player in the main menu and add him to your chosen team. Then do team franchise and player lock your guy during plays. Then you can control play calling at least and will only have to rely on dumb ai after the snap.