All Time MLB Rosters (17)

[Wdk19]

Who is interested in helping me clean up one of the existing "All Time" rosters? Currently they seem to still contain current players at their current rating, i.e. Mike Trout is 99 along with the likes of Barry Bonds, Willie Mays, Ted Williams, etc. This bugs the crap out of me and I'm trying to lower the current players' ratings to be comparable with the legends also in the roster. However, I can't do this alone so if anyone is willing, I was going to use the O.S. All Time Roster as a base. Thanks.

[OhioBobcats]

Mike Trout is a 99 still because he's a 99 all-time player.

[sc73ray]

Quote: Originally Posted by Wdk19

Who is interested in helping me clean up one of the existing "All Time" rosters? Currently they seem to still contain current players at their current rating, i.e. Mike Trout is 99 along with the likes of Barry Bonds, Willie Mays, Ted Williams, etc. This bugs the crap out of me and I'm trying to lower the current players' ratings to be comparable with the legends also in the roster. However, I can't do this alone so if anyone is willing, I was going to use the O.S. All Time Roster as a base. Thanks.

I'm just about done on an all time roster. I went through and altered ratings, equipment and adjusted all the CAPS faces, skin tones, eyes and such. All pitch types, batting stances, birthplaces are all correct. Hope to have it out this weekend.

I based the rosters on every teams all time WAR. Top 5 SP by WAR, top 6 RP by WAR...and so on and so on.

There is a backup in the vault already for the first 25 teams. But even those are getting tweaked still.

[KCRoyals]

Try the foster set Franchise Stars by dallmanator1.

KCRoyals

[Wdk19]

Quote: Originally Posted by OhioBobcats

Mike Trout is a 99 still because he's a 99 all-time player.

Trout is most definitely not in the same class as Babe Ruth, Willie Mays and Ted Williams, at least yet.

[Wdk19]

I am currently working on all-time 25 men rosters based on the website Hall of Stats (a really cool site that you should all go check out). I am taking 5 starters, 3 relievers and 4 additional pitchers for each franchise, as well as 5 infielders 4 outfielder and 1 additional fielder. I'll make a roster using these if I have the time.

[Wdk19]

Reds through Orioles

image.jpg

[Wdk19]

Reds Sox through Braves

image.jpg