Who are some of the overrated and underrated players in MLB The Show 17?

[MoneyOvaHuds]

I haven't really found many overrated but I think Javy Baez is underrated in terms of speed and his defense. He just feels very average when he's one of the best 2B defenders in the league.

https://youtu.be/xoY9IMsO_nY



https://youtu.be/-Uiq2ORGqoc

[MLBfanatic97]

Kole Calhoun is very underrated on defense, he's only got something like 55 speed but he catches everything for me

Sent from my NSA-certified cellular device

[Caulfield]

over- kershaw
I can see him being a 98, but 99? c'mon man, thats ridonculous.

under- trout, hows he not a 100? somebody in san diego got an axe to grind?

just kidding
but seriously

over-d'backs legend luis gonzalez - no way he should be rated higher than
cal ripken AND ozzie smith AND wade boggs AND robin yount AND reggie jackson
AND ernie banks AND willie stargell AND brooks robinson AND catfish hunter
AND carlton fisk AND rod carew AND probably 5 more legends

under- addison russell was an 82 in the november roster update, what happened in the off-season for him to drop?

[Bunselpower32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Caulfield

over- kershaw I can see him being a 98, but 99? c'mon man, thats ridonculous. under- trout, hows he not a 100? somebody in san diego got an axe to grind? just kidding but seriously over-d'backs legend luis gonzalez - no way he should be rated higher than cal ripken AND ozzie smith AND wade boggs AND robin yount AND reggie jackson AND ernie banks AND willie stargell AND brooks robinson AND catfish hunter AND carlton fisk AND rod carew AND probably 5 more legends under- addison russell was an 82 in the november roster update, what happened in the off-season for him to drop?

I don't know what year that card is from, but if it's 2001, I think he absolutely should be rated that high.

[Razeart2422]

Brett Gardner's Power is overrated. He is a 51 Power vs RHP and 40 against LHP meanwhile Yadier Molina is a 36 Power vs RHP and 34 vs LHP.

Brett's Career Ab/HR is 55.9
While Yadier Molina's is a 50.5

Brett should be more like a 32 Power against Rhp and 29 Power vs LHP.

[GoDucks1224]

Quote: Originally Posted by Caulfield

over- kershaw I can see him being a 98, but 99? c'mon man, thats ridonculous. under- trout, hows he not a 100? somebody in san diego got an axe to grind? just kidding but seriously over-d'backs legend luis gonzalez - no way he should be rated higher than cal ripken AND ozzie smith AND wade boggs AND robin yount AND reggie jackson AND ernie banks AND willie stargell AND brooks robinson AND catfish hunter AND carlton fisk AND rod carew AND probably 5 more legends under- addison russell was an 82 in the november roster update, what happened in the off-season for him to drop?

The ratings are based entirely on one season according to SDS, right? So 2001 Luis Gonzalez should be incredibly high rated. He was a monster that season. Drove in like 150 runs and hit 50+ bombs. Slugged some ridiculous percentage. I mean he was obviously juicing, but still lol.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Steve5696]

The fact that Gary Sanchez and Greg Bird are B potentials while Aaron Judge and Tyler Austin (WTF?) are A potentials for the Yankees is a little mind boggling

[DaltonT4]

Brandon Finnegan being a 69 overall is criminal


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports