Extra Innings Mode Broken?

[ALLMAN93]

Just played two games on All Star and it honestly felt like rookie. So, I decided to play a game on Legend to see if I could get a gold or Diamond after the game and yet again the game felt like rookie. After the game it showed 3 commons and a few bronzes and a silver. It came down to two bronzes and I got the bronze player instead of the stadium. From their percentages I should have even had a shot at commons, correct? If this is broken, that's huge because it means we can't play offline with a challenge or expect to receive the proper rewards. Now that online is broken it's all we have to play atm so it's either play on rookie or don't play at all which is pretty frustrating.

[ALLMAN93]

Anyone experienced this?

[justcallmewes]

I feel like All-Star difficulty in general is easier this year. I played mostly All Star difficulty on MLB 15 and it gave me the most realistic results for my level of play. This year's game, I'm killing it on All-Star difficulty.

[mikeq672]

Quote: Originally Posted by ALLMAN93

Just played two games on All Star and it honestly felt like rookie. So, I decided to play a game on Legend to see if I could get a gold or Diamond after the game and yet again the game felt like rookie. After the game it showed 3 commons and a few bronzes and a silver. It came down to two bronzes and I got the bronze player instead of the stadium. From their percentages I should have even had a shot at commons, correct? If this is broken, that's huge because it means we can't play offline with a challenge or expect to receive the proper rewards. Now that online is broken it's all we have to play atm so it's either play on rookie or don't play at all which is pretty frustrating.

Ive thought this too, like the game doesnt register when youre changing the difficulty or something, despite showing the improved rewards.

[DarkArrow]

Played 5 EI games. All on HOF, they played exactly like Rookie

The worst part: None of them counted (queued and never registered)

Not bothering with anything but conquest, at least those games count.

[plainfacepicasso]

Yep, I played an all diamond team on all-star and allowed only one run until the ninth inning and then gave up two more. It really does feel like it's on rookie, but I guess that's a good thing as far as getting rewards.

[mikeq672]

Just won a few games on legend to test it, was given a common player after every single game, which is supposed to be at 0%

[plainfacepicasso]

Quote: Originally Posted by mikeq672

Just won a few games on legend to test it, was given a common player after every single game, which is supposed to be at 0%

Did you win any games?