Which do you guys prefer and why?

[jayb_270]

In the fielding settings, do you use just buttons, buttons plus accuracy or pure analog. I'm using only buttons and I'm finding that I really have no control over how accurate the throw is. Routine throws turns into errors which turn into runs. I'm thinking about switching to buttons plus accuracy but not sure how hard the transition will be

[Orange Krush]

When I first started playing the triple play challenge, I switched over to button accuracy. I used the challenge to get good at it and I'll never go back. Button accuracy is to throwing what zone is to hitting. It gives you much more control over what the player does and limits random errors.

[jayb_270]

Doing the challenge now and I'm gonna try it, thanks

[Orange Krush]

Doing the community challenges is a great way to practice using it

[VowedVengeance]

100% agree with this, three games in a row I had costly errors while using just the button setting that lead to three heart breaking losses. I've since gone to button accuracy, it takes time to get used to but is a major upgrade. One throwing error in my other 7 games, now only if my dd player would stop dropping easily fly balls or run overtop ground balls I'm the alley I'd be good.

Sent from my SM-G920P using Tapatalk

[Dr Mc Tardy]

Buttons accuracy is what I've been using for a while now and I'd never look back.

[sh27]

I feel like you can't preload throws at all with button accuracy, though. Maybe I am just doing it wrong.

[Orange Krush]

I've been an advocate for button accuracy, but yesterday I tried out analog throwing, and I'm liking it more right now. With button accuracy you usually need to look at the meter to get the timing right, but with the analog stick you only need to make sure you push it exactly in the right direction to have an accurate throw. I'm going to have to experiment with both for a while to see which I like better.

Edit:
After further review, I've decided that pure analog throwing is best for me. It's so much easier to just push the stick in a direction instead of trying to time the meter. I don't even need to look at what I'm doing, which is the best part.