Is Madden 25 the best Madden Ever?

[trufootball]

I believe with this years edition of Madden we have finally eclipsed the so called glory days of Madden in the ps2 era with the improvements that have been added. But I'm curious to know how others feel? Is this the best Madden yet?

[tnixen]

I think Madden 08 on PC is overall the best Madden that I have played. Madden 25 PS4 will be the first Madden that I buy since 08 PC version.

[LowerWolf]

I'm really enjoying M25, and I think it's far and away the best this generation. But there's too many little things to say it's the best Madden ever.

[MST246]

I'm playing 12.

[mavfan21]

I only play offline CFM and haven't loaded the disc in two weeks......

BUT, once the repeating draft classes are patched and we (hopefully) can edit the white sleeve issue I think it will be my favorite Madden.

Even though I hate how XP is implemented (too complicated and the CPU doesn't allocate it well) I still like the game overall

Hopefully I can start a CFM soon.

[misterkrabz]

Quote: Originally Posted by trufootball

I believe with this years edition of Madden we have finally eclipsed the so called glory days of Madden in the ps2 era with the improvements that have been added. But I'm curious to know how others feel? Is this the best Madden yet?

Nope...the buttons still don't work on defense. Epic fail. When I press the triangle button or square button and the man I'm controlling actually does something then they'll be getting close...until then it's the same crap.

[Big FN Deal]

For me it's the best game play I have ever experienced in any Madden ever but the game as a whole, no. I don't see how any Madden can be the "best Madden ever" unless it at least matches everything still relevant to NFL football done by past Maddens and add to that. As it stands right now there are still far too many elements from past Maddens, missing, broken or inferior in Madden 25, imo.

[fletcher2332]

It's the best madden ever because of madden share. May have the same gameplay and graphics but to be able to share rosters at ease and make classics puts it up there.