Best Franchise Mode This Gen?

[econoodle]

so with CC out and about for a week or so, you guys have gotten knee deep in it and it seems to be flawed. Along with removing features that many of you guys loved.

Has it surpassed or regressed from past versions this gen?

scouting?
the draft?
menus?
logic?

I have rented every year since 08 and never purchased it, the franchise mode just never cut it.

Also, some of the thing I personally loved have been axed [the extra point show, yes i loved it] and things i hated have been made better [commentary] and there r still things I haven't seen added [holdouts, assistant coaches, score tickers].

With that being said.
best one yet, franchise wise?
I am ready to turn in my copy of madden 07 ps2 and play a next gen madden, preferably 13, but man those user reviews on amazon and here aren't making me feel good as an offline franchise guy.

help a brother out.

[TeamBuilder]

I'm hesitant to recommend getting Madden 13 right away if you're a core offline franchise guy. Connected Careers has its problems. Waiting until a patch is released may be your best move at this point in time.

[Obnoxious]

CCM has a bright future but the current sim stats and scores makes it unplayable for me. I'm hesitant to buy Madden 07.

[Dogslax41]

Best advice for offline franchisee is wait until after Tuesday to see how the patch works. As it is right now, offline is missing some key things from online (xp increase and scheme save issue) that make it not really worth investing time into right now.

Scouting, the best so far
Draft, the best so far
Menus, not very user friendly
Logic, about on par with previous games. It does some things fantastically and some things it stumbles. I would say its a wash given it does a lot of things correctly that past maddens got wrong but different logic issues arise.

If you absolutely have to edit players don't even bother picking the game up. There has already been far too many people that knew editing wasn't in, bought the game anyway and have done nothing but whail to the heavens about how this game does nothing right.

[PioneerRaptor]

CCM is definitely going to be the future of the career mode in sports game. I can already see the potential growth that will come when they are able to implement the old features back into the game.

However, because of some bugs (none that I consider groundbreaking) and the removal of a lot of a lot of features (which I understand why) stops CCM from being the best we've seen this generation.

I have no doubt though, that it will be the best very soon.

[DrewsLions]

I think it really depends on what you are looking for. If you like to waste time in practices "powering up" your coach or player or get into all the XP stuff, maybe you'll find it better. For me, I am trying like hell to love this game, but so far, it's just not happening. I don't want to waste a half hour to an hour between every regular season game getting "power ups" and manually progressing players. I just sim it all.

What I am looking for is a fully customizable, immersive franchise with good presentation elements. Presentation is a shade better here, but the customization is zilch and you are forced to take over as a coach or player... no more "God" or GM role that allows you to do what you will within "your" league. Feels so very restrictive. The twitter feeds and news stories are somewhat cool and to an extent add some immersion, but they often feel scripted, stale and repetitive... and I'm only in the fourth game of my franchise. Good luck getting a feel for standings and stats... they are so buried in the menus that the rest of the league feels miles away. That is not immersion. Remember when the league schedule was the main menu and you knew who was playing who and who had what record? Add that to the news stories and twitter and you have something.

So far, when you mix that with the many bugs in this game, it just melds into a huge pile of "meh". Gameplay really isn't much better. I've waited for RTP forever and I get a rushed version with so much unnatural activity that I just sit and shake my head. Too bad. Parts of it do feel better, just not better enough. I've heard this was built from the ground up, yet some of the same problems are still there... (super-human-jumping-intercepting linebacker, anyone?)

At the end of the day, I once again spent $60 on something that makes me go Shame on me......

[DrewsLions]

Quote: Originally Posted by PioneerRaptor

I have no doubt though, that it will be the best very soon.

Better be. They've certainly had enough attempts at it......

[ajk49er]

with the right fixes, its not even close.