Best baseball game on 360?

[codyj123_321]

I'm gonna go buy one today, which do you all say is the most realistic and has the best gameplay?

[jeffy777]

2K11 (or 2K12) is the only option if you want something fairly realistic. The only other option is The Bigs, but that's full-on arcade.

[tvman]

I'd pick up highheat 2004 for original xbox (cheap if you can find it), graphics are a lot better on the 360.

[queensbomber]

Is this a trick question?

[Schreck]

2k12 comes out next Tuesday, so you can either wait til then or pick up 2k11 for cheap today.

[buckeyedawgtribe]

Quote: Originally Posted by codyj123_321

I'm gonna go buy one today, which do you all say is the most realistic and has the best gameplay?

2K12 of course..improbved graphics (pretty much closed the gap on the show from what I have seen). MLB today..great online play...As long as they fixed the glitches from last year..we could have a winner on our hands.

You will love the pitching and the pitcher/batter duels in this game..it is so much more realistic than the old golf meter system that I have seen in MLB the show..enoy

[jhols1nger]

MLB 2K12 I would imagine.

[zoguloth22]

Quote: Originally Posted by buckeyedawgtribe

2K12 of course..improbved graphics (pretty much closed the gap on the show from what I have seen). MLB today..great online play...As long as they fixed the glitches from last year..we could have a winner on our hands. You will love the pitching and the pitcher/batter duels in this game..it is so much more realistic than the old golf meter system that I have seen in MLB the show..enoy

The graphics don't even come close to the show, so i don't see why you would say that. and there are 4 diffrent ways to pitch in the show. but after looking looks like you only have the 360 so you realy don't have much of a choice. Not saying 2k will be bad there are areas of 2k Baseball i like but they would need to have another three years to come close game play wise to the show.