Official 2K12 Rate My Trade

[Cossolotto32]

The other thread is dead, so I thought might as well start another one up for this year, so feel free to leave your trades for comments!

[nowitsourtime]

In my association, Danny Granger wants out of Indiana. I'm the Bobcats. We're sitting at 12-11 in December and I think we have a chance at making a push. Is the following trade fair?

Get: Danny Granger, James Posey, Jeff Foster
Give: Garrett Temple, Corey Maggette, Boris Diaw and '12 first round draft pick.

Is the trade fair or should I insert Bismack Biyombo for Diaw to make it more fair?

[illWILL8455]

Quote: Originally Posted by nowitsourtime

In my association, Danny Granger wants out of Indiana. I'm the Bobcats. We're sitting at 12-11 in December and I think we have a chance at making a push. Is the following trade fair? Get: Danny Granger, James Posey, Jeff Foster Give: Garrett Temple, Corey Maggette, Boris Diaw and '12 first round draft pick. Is the trade fair or should I insert Bismack Biyombo for Diaw to make it more fair?

Basicly the only things of any value to the Pacers in that deal is the pick, and Diaw's expiring contract, however, Maggettes contract is awful and Temple will never see the floor in Indy due to their dept at the SG position. From a realistic prospective, Indy knows they can get more for their franchise player then a deal where they lose their star, for a 1st and an expiring, a horrible contract, and a scrub

All that being said, maybe what you should look to do is find a third team to deal with to make the deal more realistic. Maybe a team that could use Diaw, and maybe pick between DJ or Kemba and trade the other one to the Pacers, or the third team in the deal. Unless the Pacers roster has changed much in your association you will probably have to look to trade DJ somewhere else, because the Pacers have two great PGs.

*Great thread! The other one was great but has died lol

[DJ2Kay]

i like this thread...

[illWILL8455]

Just for fun, and possible association ideas, with all that has been in the news lately, what are some scenarios you guys can come up with on where CP3 and Dwight Howard will be dealt before the trade deadline? This should be fun!

Lets get this thread going strong, leave all thoughts and feedback!

[nowitsourtime]

Quote: Originally Posted by illWILL8455

Basicly the only things of any value to the Pacers in that deal is the pick, and Diaw's expiring contract, however, Maggettes contract is awful and Temple will never see the floor in Indy due to their dept at the SG position. From a realistic prospective, Indy knows they can get more for their franchise player then a deal where they lose their star, for a 1st and an expiring, a horrible contract, and a scrub All that being said, maybe what you should look to do is find a third team to deal with to make the deal more realistic. Maybe a team that could use Diaw, and maybe pick between DJ or Kemba and trade the other one to the Pacers, or the third team in the deal. Unless the Pacers roster has changed much in your association you will probably have to look to trade DJ somewhere else, because the Pacers have two great PGs. *Great thread! The other one was great but has died lol

I traded the 1st round draft pick, Bismack Biyombo and Corey Maggette for Granger and Jason Kapono (they got him from the 76ers). Hopefully Granger will take over the lead scorer role

[illWILL8455]

Quote: Originally Posted by nowitsourtime

I traded the 1st round draft pick, Bismack Biyombo and Corey Maggette for Granger and Jason Kapono (they got him from the 76ers). Hopefully Granger will take over the lead scorer role

2012 1st or the 2013 1st? I feel like thats a tough deal if you let the 2012 first go because the 2012 draft class is loaded if most of the talent enters the draft. Basicly we could keep Bismack, struggle through Maggette, and then draft a Harrison Barnes, Terrence Jones, Anthony Davis, etc. I feel like a move like yours, Charlotte would almost become a win now team, with a crappy low post, an unproven back court, and one star in Granger. Thats the recipe for mediocrity which is where we are trying to get away from.

Just my feed back on that trade if you are trying to make it realistic. In 2k12 that is a great trade because Granger is a beast. I can score with DJ at will too so that makes for a pretty good offensive team despite the fact that it would struggle in real life.

[nowitsourtime]

I traded the 2012 first. To each their own. I didn't really feel like struggling through the rebuilding process with piece that I didn't know would fall into place. My plan is to drop Diaw once his salary expires and get a good low post scorer (Hopefully Dwight Howard) in the free agent market with the cap room I'll get.