Road to Glory Unrealistic Heisman Trophy

[Quique987987]

I created my Road to Glory player as a dual-threat quarterback. My sophomore year I finished 2nd in Heisman voting behind a running back that had about 200 more yards than myself. I was alright with that because he was Nebraska's (my team) running back. My junior year I won the Heisman by almost 1600 votes. My main problem is because of what happened my senior year. I lead the NCAA in rushing yards, rushing td's, yards per carry, and passing efficiency while being 3rd in passing yards and td's on a 13-0 BCS national championship-bound team. I came in 2nd place by over 1000 votes to a running back that had over 300 less yards, 5 less td's, and averaged 4 less yards per carry on an 11-3 Oregon team that ended up playing an unranked Missouri team in the Alamo Bowl. Has anyone else had this problem?

[Equinox831]

If you have unrealistic stats, then you won't get the trophy. What were your stats exactly?

[NDAlum]

They should give people the option to assign the Heisman

It would eliminate this issue

[Quique987987]

I had about 3,700 yards and 33 td's passing and 1,700 yards and 21 td's rushing. If that's true it kinda bothers me, seeing as Bradford, Tebow, and Newton all had unrealistic numbers and won the trophy.

[Equinox831]

Quote: Originally Posted by Quique987987

I had about 3,700 yards and 33 td's passing and 1,700 yards and 21 td's rushing. If that's true it kinda bothers me, seeing as Bradford, Tebow, and Newton all had unrealistic numbers and won the trophy.

Well if they did it in real life, then it's not unrealistic.. I think your rushing totals might have kept you from winning it, but honestly you probably should have won.

[Quique987987]

Quote: Originally Posted by Equinox831

Well if they did it in real life, then it's not unrealistic.. I think your rushing totals might have kept you from winning it, but honestly you probably should have won.

Well clearly lol, I just mean that Bradford and Tebow both accounted for more td's than I did and almost as many yards. I'll just have to remember not to be so good next time.

[BGarrett7]

Quote: Originally Posted by Quique987987

I had about 3,700 yards and 33 td's passing and 1,700 yards and 21 td's rushing. If that's true it kinda bothers me, seeing as Bradford, Tebow, and Newton all had unrealistic numbers and won the trophy.

Tebow - Passing: 3286/32 | Rushing: 895/23
Newton: Passing: 2854/30 | Rushing: 1473/20
You: Passing: 3700/33 | Rushing: 1700/21

You had 500 more yards passing than Football Jesus and 300 more rushing yards than Newton... Not really comparable.

Pat White, VY, Randle El or Crouch even approached those rushing numbers, much less having both those on the ground and almost 4000 in the air.

[Quique987987]

Quote: Originally Posted by BGarrett7

Tebow - Passing: 3286/32 | Rushing: 895/23 Newton: Passing: 2854/30 | Rushing: 1473/20 You: Passing: 3700/33 | Rushing: 1700/21 You had 500 more yards passing than Football Jesus and 300 more rushing yards than Newton... Not really comparable. Pat White, VY, Randle El or Crouch even approached those rushing numbers, much less having both those on the ground and almost 4000 in the air.

Denard Robinson did it last season, at least rushing. Just because a player didn't do it, doesn't mean they couldn't have. How many games did those players get taken out of early? My team's defense was horrible. There were multiple 3 OT games with 50+ points. I'm pretty sure Tommie Frazier could've put up about 2500 yards his senior year.