Pass Reaction 0 and how to relates to Realistic QB% and accuarcy

[Playmakers]

I've been kinda under the table slowly piecing together some passing game sliders that actually render true numbers based on ratings for the starting QB's only

This formula is only calculated based on non-lead passing which i believe is the best way to take advantage of EA's assigned in game ratings for all QB's

I don't have all the starters done yet but for an example I'll use Ton Brady and Drew Brees

Brady's avg accuarcy rating based on Accuarcy, Short, Medium, Long and Throw on the Run is 86.2 between the 5 ratings

Based on the 100 QBA range the Human would utilize the lower end of the scale and the CPU would utilize the higher end of the game to simulate true in game accuarcy

Brady's Human setting would be 13.8 rounded up to 14....Human slider would be set at 14 if you control Tom Brady

CPU Tom Brady setting would be 86 on the slider if you play against New England

Drew Brees avg was 89.8 overall accuarcy rounded up to 90 which translates to 10.2 on the human slider basically 10

The CPU controlled Brees would get a 90 QBA setting

Now here's how the defense would be set up to show you what i'm speaking about in these formulas

Human Pass defense vs Tom Brady
Pass Reaction-0
INT-50
Pass Rush-50

CPU Pass Offense under Tom Brady
QBA-86
Pass Block-50
Wr Catch-50.........Do not touch this slider his wr catch ratings will factor into true completion percentages

Human Offense with Brady
QBA-14
Pass Block-50
Wr Catch-50

CPU Defense vs Human controlled Tom Brady
Pass Reaction-0
INT-0..................This setting is used as starting point to take out all other variables which may alter completion percentages
Pass Rush-0
-------------------------------------
Human Pass Defense vs Drew Brees
Pass Reaction-0
INT-50
Pass Rush-50

CPU Offense under Brees
QBA-90
Pass Block-50
Wr catch-50

Human Offense with Brees
QBA-10
Pass Block-50
WR Catch-50

CPU Defense vs Brees
Pass Reaction-0
INT-0
Pass Rush-0

These are the only sliders you should observe right now as they strictly focus on the passing game to simulate true accuarcy and percentages

Some Pass Defense settings will change as I determine values for them later. But the Reaction slider will always be at 0 on both sides of the ball.

[drj32]

If Brady is a 14, this means a human controlled Tavaris Jackson should be a 1 or 2 setting?

thanks

[Playmakers]

Full List of QBA ratings put together by whosnext00 Plus a WR Catch slider i've inlcuded for All QB's controlled by the Human player only.

QB | AVG | HUM | CPU
Anderson, Derek 66.4 34 66......(Wr Catch-41)
Bartel, Richard 66.6 33 67........(Wr Catch-40)
Batch, Charlie 68.6 31 69.........(WR Catch-38)
Beck, John 71.4 29 71.............(Wr Catch-46)
Boller, Kyle 67 33 67...............(WR Catch-42)
Bomar, Rhett 72.6 27 73..........(WR Catch-48)
Bouman, Todd 72.6 27 73........(WR Catch-48)
Bradford, Sam 86.2 14 86........(Wr Catch-61)
Brady, Tom 86.2 14 86............(WR Catch-61)
Brandstater, Tom 68.2 32 68....(WR Catch-43)
Brees, Drew 89.8 10 90...........(WR Catch-65)
Brohm, Brian 73.2 27 73..........(WR Catch-48)
Brown, Levi 76 24 76..............(WR Catch-51)
Brown, Jarrett 72.6 27 73........(Wr Catch-48)
Brunell, Mark 71.8 28 72..........(WR Catch-47)
Campbell, Jason 78.4 22 78......(WR Catch-53)
Canfield, Sean 71.6 28 72........(WR Catch-47)
Cantwell, Hunter 67.2 33 67.....(WR Catch-42)
Carpenter, Rudy 69 31 69........(WR Catch-44)
Carr, David 69.4 31 69............(WR Catch-44)
Cassel, Matt 80.2 20 80..........(WR Catch-55)
Clausen, Jimmy 77.4 23 77.......(WR Catch-52)
Clemens, Kellen 68.8 31 69.......(WR Catch-44)
Collins, Kerry 68 32 68.............(WR Catch-43)
Crompton, Jonathan 75.8 24 76..(WR Catch-51)
Croyle, Brodie 68.4 32 68..........(Wr Catch-43)
Cutler, Jay 82.2 18 82..............(WR Catch-57)
Dalton, Andy 78.8 21 79............(WR Catch-54)
Daniel, Chase 74.2 26 74...........(WR catch-49)
Davis, Nate 74.8 25 75..............(WR Catch-50)
Delhomme, Jake 70.6 29 71........(WR Catch-46)
Delvin, Pat 72.4 28 72...............(WR Catch-47)
Dixon, Dennis 73.4 27 73...........(WR Catch-48)
Edwards, Trent 70.6 29 71.........(WR Catch-46)
Enderle, Nathan 67.4 33 67........(WR Catch-42)
Feeley, A.J. 72 28 72................(Wr Catch-47)
Fitzpatrick, Ryan 80 20 80.........(WR Catch-55)
Flacco, Joe 82.4 18 82..............(WR Catch-57)
Flynn, Matt 78.8 21 79..............(Wr Catch-54)
Freeman, Josh 85.6 14 86.........(WR Catch-61)
Frye, Charlie 72 28 72..............(WR Catch-47)
Gabbert, Blaine 82 18 82..........(Wr Catch-57)
Garrard, David 78.4 22 78.........(WR Catch-53)
Gradkowski, Bruce 78.4 22 78.....(WR Catch-53)
Greisen, Chris 68.8 29 69...........(WR Catch-46)
Grossman, Rex 70 30 70............(WR Catch-45)
Gutierrez, Matt 71 29 71...........(WR Catch-46)
Hall, Max 70.4 30 70................(WR Catch-45)
Hanie, Caleb 72.6 27 73...........(WR Catch-48)
Harrell, Graham 73 27 73..........(WR Catch-48)
Hasselbeck, Matt 77.6 22 78.....(WR Catch-53)
Hayes, Doug 68.6 31 69...........(WR Catch-44)
Henne, Chad 76.6 23 77...........(WR Catch-52)
Hill, Shaun 77.8 22 78..............(WR catch-53)
Hoyer, Brian 70.2 30 70............(WR Catch-45)
Jackson, Tarvaris 72.4 28 72.....(WR Catch-47)
Johnson, Josh 70.8 29 71.........(WR catch-46)
Johnson, Jerrod 69.4 31 69.......(WR catch-44)
Kaepernick, Colin 78.6 21 79......(WR Catch-54)
Kafka, Mike 69.6 30 70............(Wr Catch-45)
Kitna, Jon 69.2 31 69...............(WR Catch-44)
Kolb, Kevin 81.8 18 82.............(WR Catch-57)
Lefevour, Dan 70.2 30 70.........(WR Catch-45)
Leftwich, Byron 64.6 35 65.......(WR Catch-40)
Leinart, Matt 68.6 31 69..........(WR Catch-44)
Lewis, Thaddeus 65.8 34 66.....(WR Catch-41)
Locker, Jake 79.8 20 80...........(WR Catch-55)
Losman, J.P. 67.8 32 68...........(WR Catch-43)
Mallett, Ryan 71.6 28 72..........(WR Catch-47)
Manning, Eli 79.8 20 80...........(WR Catch-55)
Manning, Peyton 87 13 87.........(WR Catch-62)
McCown, Luke 75 25 75..........(WR Catch-50)
McCown, Josh 75 25 75..........(WR Catch-50)
McCoy, Colt 82.4 18 82...........(Wr Catch-57)
McElroy, Greg 71.2 29 71.........(WR Catch-46)
McGee, Stephen 71.6 28 72.....(WR Catch-47)
McNabb, Donovan 76.2 24 76...(WR Catch-51)
Moore, Matt 73.4 37 73...........(WR Catch-38)
Newton, Cam 82.4 18 82..........(Wr Catch-57)
Null, Keith 68 32 68.................(WR Catch-43)
O'Connell, Kevin 68.4 32 68......(WR Catch-43)
Orlovsky, Dan 74 26 74...........(WR catch-49)
Orton, Kyle 76.8 23 77............(WR Catch-52)
Painter, Curtis 67.8 32 68........(WR Catch-43)
Palko, Tyler 68.4 32 68............(WR Catch-43)
Palmer, Jordan 67.6 32 68........(WR Catch-43)
Palmer, Carson 75.6 24 76.......(WR Catch-51)
Pike, Tony 75.4 25 75.............(WR Catch-50)
Ponder, Christian 82.6 17 83.....(WR Catch-58)
Portis, Josh 68.6 31 69............(WR catch-44)
Pryor, Terrelle 74.2 26 74.........(WR Catch-49)
Quinn, Brady 72.6 27 73...........(WR Catch-48)
Ratliff, Brett 67.8 32 68...........(WR Catch-43)
Redman, Chris 71 29 71............(WR Catch-46)
Rivers, Philip 87 13 87..............(WR Catch-62)
Robinson, Zac 69 31 69............(WR Catch-44)
Rodgers, Aaron 92 8 92............(WR catch-67)
Roethlisberger, Ben 90 10 90.....(WR Catch-65)
Romo, Tony 85.8 14 86............(WR catch-61)
Rosenfels, Sage 76 24 76.........(WR Catch-51)
Russell, jamarcus 62.2 38 62.....(WR Catch-37)
Ryan, Matt 84 16 84................(WR Catch-59)
Sanchez, Mark 81 19 81...........(WR Catch-56)
Schaub, Matt 78.4 22 78..........(Wr Catch-53)
Simms, Chris 69.8 30 70..........(WR Catch-45)
Skelton, John 72.2 28 72..........(WR Catch-47)
Smith, Troy 74 26 74................(WR Catch-49)
Smith, Brad 66.4 34 66.............(WR Catch-41)
Smith, Alex 78.4 22 78..............(WR Catch-53)
Smith, Rusty 65.8 34 66............(WR Catch-41)
Sorgi, Jim 68 32 68...................(WR Catch-43)
Stafford, Matthew 77.4 23 77.....(WR Catch-52)
Stanton, Drew 74.2 26 74..........(WR Catch-49)
Stanzi, Ricky 74.4 26 74............(WR Catch-49)
Taylor, Tyrod 71.6 28 72...........(WR Catch-47)
Tebow, Tim 75.4 25 75..............(WR Catch-50)
Thigpen, Tyler 75.4 25 75..........(WR Catch-50)
Tolzien, Scott 70 30 70.............(WR Catch-45)
Vick, Michael 88 12 88...............(WR Catch-63)
Volek, Billy 72.8 27 73................(WR Catch-48)
Wallace, Seneca 75.6 24 76........(WR Catch-51)
Webb, Joe 70.6 29 71................(WR Catch-46)
Whitehurst, Charlie 74.8 25 75.....(WR Catch-50)
Willy, Drew 68.8 31 69...............(WR Catch-44)
Wilson, John Parker 64 36 64.......(WR Catch-39)
Yates, T.J. 74.8 25 75...............(WR Catch-50)
Young, Vince 78.6 21 79............(WR Catch-55)

[Chedapalooza]

I like it a lot.. How so we apply this on a large scale level for all qbs?? I wouldn't mind adjusting for every game so long as there's a somewhat simple method to the madness. I would gladly adjust to obtain real life gameplay . .. How about rushing?

[Playmakers]

Updated entire list moved to the 3rd post for now.

[Playmakers]

Quote: Originally Posted by Chedapalooza

I like it a lot.. How so we apply this on a large scale level for all qbs?? I wouldn't mind adjusting for every game so long as there's a somewhat simple method to the madness. I would gladly adjust to obtain real life gameplay . .. How about rushing?

You can take the avg of all QB's and then make that your basic setting for both Human and CPU QBA slider or you can do like i will be doing and just adjust the CPU Slider game by game for the QB you'll be playing

For example Tony Romo in franshise will be set at QBA-14 i will not have to change that slider because he's the only QB i'll be using but the CPU slider will change from game to game as mentioned above.

The WR catch Slider will always be at 50 and it keeps Completion and accuarcy ratings accurate for all QB's

[Playmakers]

I've tested these settings with most of the QB's listed and it is amazing to see how they react....

Peyton Manning is awesome with these settings

The other key sliders are WR catch and Pass Block they must remain at 50 in order to Simulate to true QB percentages.

Wr Catch slider also effects route running as you'll see some guys totally screw up a route and makes the pass look off target and out of reach by the defender and Wr

I think EA did a damn good job with the game this year capturing realism but the trick is use the Reaction sliders as a starting point and keep as many sliders close to 50 as possible with the accpetion of certain sliders that need to adjust do to the reaction slider going down in pass coverage

[KBLover]

This is some very interesting stuff.

So WR catching and pass block should stay at 50...do you still get a good pass rush from the better D-Linemen or on blitz packages?

Likewise, with human pass reaction at 0 and QB Acc for CPU at 92 - what kind of completion % do you see on average? That would seem like it would be super easy to carve you up, no matter what kind of defenders you have (or WR they are covering).

I don't know if I'll switch each time (I feel like there should be some combo of settings that will just let ratings express themselves and between DPP, player ratings and game ebb/flow, things come out), but there's some things in here to think about.