Help! 2k7 or 2k8?!

[kg54mvp1]

Hey guys I have a ps3 and I have had 2k11 for a while and am getting tired of it. I don't want the show. But I can't decide whether to get 2k7 or 2k8. Here is what I think

1) I heard the framerate is awful on the ps3 version of 2k8
2) and I heard the graphics were better in 2k7

What do you guys think!?!?

[Rouchicus]

You have a PS3 and you want a baseball game....but you don't want The Show?

[kg54mvp1]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rouchicus

You have a PS3 and you want a baseball game....but you don't want The Show?

Already have it. Sorry for not explaining. I have had it since day one, then later I got 2k11. But just want something different. I wanted to get either 2k7 or 2k8 because they looked fun and are something different.

[Rouchicus]

lol just not very often you hear about someone with a PS3 who wants a baseball game but has ruled out The Show.

[NotoriousReignz]

If you want a fun baseball game on the PS3 besides The Show, then I recommend Pro Yakyuu Spirits 2011

[CrazyKitchenGuy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Rouchicus

lol just not very often you hear about someone with a PS3 who wants a baseball game but has ruled out The Show.

To be honest, the Show, doesn't really have as much of that "Wow" factor as it once did.

For me, The Show plays a great game, but its far better with the sound off. I'm hearing commentary in the game that I heard when I first got into the game back in '06.

The dynamic commentary that 2K11 offers, plus the realistic analog pitching, compared to the "attempt" that the Show made, makes it a worthwhile contender on the PS3, contrary to popular belief.

[mkharsh33]

I love 2K11. With slider tweaks it's possibly the best baseball game I've played since MVP 05 for the old xbox. I don't have a PS3 so I cannot comment on The Show (never played it). But having played 2k7 and 2k8 I'd never go back to either of those having played 2k11.

[kg54mvp1]

But if anyone had to choose between the two. Which is better and why?!?!