IGN Review Thread

[ggazoo]

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/115/1154449p1.html

[mooch49]

the review is very accurate, but the score is underwhelming. the game should have got at least a 9

[Tully]

Quote: Originally Posted by mooch49

the review is very accurate, but the score is underwhelming. the game should have got at least a 9

Why? They didn't add much. This could be MLB10.5

[Jgainsey]

It seems like all of the "big name" review sites give almost every sports title a random 8 - 9 score each year. I don't know if they have a bunch of writers who aren't all that into sports or what, but unless the game is a complete lemon, it's really hard to take they're overall scores seriously.

[mooch49]

Quote: Originally Posted by Tully

Why? They didn't add much. This could be MLB10.5

i respectfully disagree. on face value, it may be MLB 10.5, but there are a lot of improvements under the hood. as a total package, this game is sport bliss and baseball heaven. it should have been rewarded with a higher score.

[RoyalBoyle78]

This is why IGN has just been so sad over the years.

This made me laugh. Graphics- "The stadiums don't have much visual pop or wow factor"


Are you kidding me, the stadiums are what make the graphics what they are and that's amazing, This is why I only go to IGN just for news updates, they are truly pathetic.

[hawks223]

Quote: Originally Posted by Tully

Why? They didn't add much. This could be MLB10.5

Personally I think this game is leaps and bounds better than 10. I was playing 10 for a couple weeks leading up to the release of 11 to get back into the flow. I've noticed huged differences.

[FreezeTime]

I'm expecting the gametrailers score to give the game a little more justice. 8 is a good score but considering 10 got a higher score from IGN and 11 is better in pretty much every way, it goes to show you their score is too low.