Custom Madden NFL 11 Roster, Re-rating whole NFL ... Details inside! (Finished).

[Competitor]

Look I am getting tired of all the rating IMO being so high so I just wanted to re rate the entire NFL while making it to where at each position the superstars will be given credit! For example I just finished all the QBs and it came out pretty good IMO.

Examples:

Jay Cutler - 79 OVR
Caleb Hanie - 63 OVR
Todd Collins - 50 OVR (he plays like he is 50 in real life to AHHH)

Here is the top ten QBs or the tops QBs that come up when you bring up the ALL NFL for QBs.

Quote:

Offense Spoiler Quarter Backs ------------------------- Tom Brady - 95 OVR Peyton Manning - 94 OVR Arron Rodgers - 89 OVR Drew Brees - 88 OVR Philip Rivers - 87 OVR Ben Roethlisberger - 86 OVR Micheal Vick - 85 OVR Matt Ryan - 84 OVR Matt Schaub - 83 OVR Tony Romo - 82 OVR Running Backs ------------------------- Arian Foster - 94 OVR Adrian Peterson - 93 OVR Chris Johnson - 92 OVR Maurice Jones-Drew - 91 OVR Jamaal Charles - 90 OVR Steven Jackson - 89 OVR Frank Gore - 88 OVR Ray Rice - 87 OVR Micheal Turner - 86 OVR Matt Forte - 85 OVR Full Backs ---------------------- Ovie Mugelli - 88 OVR Vonta Leach - 87 OVR Leonard Weaver - 86 OVR Le'Ron MacClain - 85 OVR Lawrence Vickers - 84 OVR Tony Richardson - 83 OVR Lousaka Polite - 82 OVR Ahmard Hall - 81 OVR Mike Karney - 80 OVR Greg Jones - 79 OVR Wide Receivers ------------------------- Andre Johnson - 93 OVR Roddy White - 92 OVR Reggie Wayne - 91 OVR Larry Fitzgerald - 90 OVR Greg Jennings - 89 OVR Calvin Johnson - 88 OVR Brandon Marshall - 87 OVR Desean Jackson - 86 OVR Dwayne Bowe - 85 OVR Wes Welker - 85 OVR Tight Ends ---------------------- Antonio Gates - 94 OVR Jason Witten - 93 OVR Vernon Davis - 92 OVR Dallas Clark - 91 OVR Tony Gonzalez - 90 OVR JerMicheal Finley - 89 OVR Mercedes Lewis - 88 OVR Zach Miller - 87 OVR Heath Miller - 86 OVR Kellen Winslow - 85 OVR Greg Olson - 84 OVR Left Tackles ------------------------- Jake Long - 92 OVR Joe Thomas - 91 OVR Ryan Clady - 90 OVR Michael Roos - 89 OVR D'Brickashaw - 88 OVR Jordan Gross - 87 OVR Jason Peters - 86 OVR Marcus McNeill - 85 OVR Matt Light -84 OVR Branden Albert - 82 OVR Left Guards ------------------------------ Carl Nicks - 88 OVR Ben Grubbs - 87 OVR Kris Dielman - 86 OVR Steve Hutchinson - 85 OVR Logan Mankins - 84 OVR Brian Waters - 83 OVR Todd Herremans - 82 OVR Mike Iupati - 81 OVR Alan Feneca - 80 OVR Robert Gallery - 79 OVR Centers --------------------------------- Nick Mangold - 91 OVR Jeff Saturday - 89 OVR Matt Birk - 88 OVR Shaun O'Hara - 87 OVR Andre Gurode - 86 OVR Ryan Kalil - 85 OVR Jason Brown - 84 OVR Todd McClure - 83 OVR Alex Mack - 82 OVR Dan Koppen - 81 OVR Right Guards --------------------------------- Jahri Evans - 91 OVR Chris Snee - 88 OVR Josh Sitton - 87 OVR Brandon Moore - 85 OVR Davin Joseph - 84 OVR Leonard Davis - 82 OVR Bobbie Williams- 80 OVR Harvey Dahl - 79 OVR Ryan Lilja - 78 OVR Uche Nwaneri - 77 OVR Right Tackles --------------------------------- Eric Winston - 84 OVR Tyson Clabo - 83 OVR Damien Woody - 82 OVR David Stewart - 81 OVR Jon Stinchcomb - 80 OVR Vernon Carey - 78 OVR Jason Smith - 76 OVR Kareem McKenzie - 75 OVR Jared Gaither - 74 OVR Ryan Harris - 72 0VR

Quote:

Defense Spoiler Left Defensive Ends -------------------------- Justin Tuck - 91 OVR Robert Mathis - 90 OVR Jason Babin - 89 OVR Chris Long - 88 OVR Charles Johnson - 87 OVR Ray Edwards - 86 OVR Aaron Smith - 85 OVR Shaun Ellis - 84 OVR Cliff Avril- 83 OVR Chris Clemons - 82 OVR Right Defensive Ends --------------------------- Julius Peppers - 95 OVR Haloti Ngata - 94 OVR Mario Williams - 93 OVR Trent Cole - 92 OVR Jared Allen - 91 OVR Dwight Freeney - 90 OVR John Abraham - 89 OVR Darnell Docket- 88 OVR Cullen Jenkins - 87 OVR Osi Umenyiora - 86 OVR Defensive Tackles -------------------------- Kevin Williams - 93 OVR Vice Wilfork - 92 OVR Richard Seymour - 91 OVR Kyle Williams - 90 OVR Shaun Rogers - 89 OVR Jay Ratliff - 88 OVR Kris Jenkins - 87 OVR Casey Hampton - 86 OVR Sedrick Ellis - 85 OVR Ndamukong Suh - 84 OVR Left Outside Linebacker ------------------------ Jon Beason - 92 OVR Clay Mathews - 91 OVR Lamarr Woodley - 90 OVR Shaun Phillips - 89 OVR Daryl Smith - 88 OVR Thomas Davis - 87 OVR Matt Roth - 86 OVR Rey Maualuga - 85 OVR Kieth Bulluck - 84 OVR Anthony Spencer - 83 OVR Middle Linebackers ------------------------- Patrick Willis - 95 OVR Brian Urlacher - 94 OVR Ray Lewis - 93 OVR David Harris -90 OVR Karlos Dansby - 89 OVR Jerod Mayo - 88 OVR Lawrence Timmons - 87 OVR Jonathan Vilma - 86 OVR Bart Scott - 85 OVR Curtis Lofton - 84 OVR Right Outside Linebacker ------------------------- Demarcus Ware - 92 OVR Lance Briggs - 91 OVR James Harrison - 90 OVR Terrell Suggs - 89 OVR Elvis Dumervil - 88 OVR Tambi Hali - 87 OVR Cameron Wake - 86 OVR Kamerion Wimbley - 85 OVR Chad Greenway - 84 OVR Brian Orakpo - 83 OVR Corner Backs ------------------------ Nnamdi Asomugha - 95 OVR Darrelle Revis - 94 OVR Champ Bailey - 93 OVR Charles Woodson - 92 OVR Asante Samuel - 91 OVR Tramon Williams - 90 OVR Brandon Flowers - 89 OVR Leon Hall - 88 OVR Cortlan Finnegan - 87 OVR Rashean Mathis - 86 OVR Jabari Greer- 85 OVR Free Safeties -------------------------- Ed Reed - 94 OVR Nick Collins - 93 OVR Antoine Bethea - 92 OVR Oshiomogho Atogwe - 91 OVR Michael Griffin - 90 OVR Kerry Rhodes - 89 OVR Brian Dawkins - 88 OVR Eric Weddle - 87 OVR Tanard Jackson - 86 OVR Brandon Meriweather - 85 OVR Strong Safeties ----------------------------- Troy Polamalu - 95 OVR Laron Landry - 91 OVR Adrian Wilson - 90 OVR Tyvon Branch - 89 OVR Yeremiah Bell - 88 OVR Bob Sanders - 87 OVR Eric Berry - 86 OVR Patrick Chung - 85 OVR Quintin Mikell - 84 OVR Dawan Landry - 83 OVR

Quote:

Special Teams Spoiler Kickers --------------------------------- Robbie Gould - 92 OVR Bob Bironas - 91 OVR Nate Kaeding - 90 OVR Ryan Longwell - 89 OVR David Akers - 88 OVR Sebastian Janikowski - 87 OVR Dan Carpenter - 86 OVR Josh Brown - 85 OVR Jay Feely- 84 OVR John Kasay - 83 OVR Punters --------------------------------- Shane Lechler - 91 OVR Sam Koch - 88 OVR Andy Lee - 87 OVR Donnie Jones - 85 OVR Mike Scrifres - 84 OVR Mat McBriar - 81 OVR Dustin Colquitt - 80 OVR Brian Moorman - 79 OVR Jon Ryan - 78 OVR Daniel Sepulveda - 77 OVR

Okay so I am pretty sure that you guys are asking me why I have Arron Rodgers not on the top of the list, I just don't think that he is a Peyton Manning or Tom Brady. The reason Brady is on the top is because he is AP NFL MVP or some thing of that nature. Peyton Manning may have thrown as many INTs he did but IMO is still a top QB. He changes the game around him with the crap that goes around him. So I just want to know what you guys think! Also any suggestions? Also I am going to be putting up these rosters on MediaFire (think that is what it is called) for all the files! Thanks for any feedback!

Small notes here, I gave Jerricho Cotchery a 99 TGH ratings because of this play...http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qzr1bTPxDzk also the loud mouths have got down all the way to 78, both of them. the ones from Cincinnati! Moss is a 76 now

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

UPDATES- http://www.mediafire.com/?9ha5b21uyzyhi47
The ROSTER HAS BEEN FINISHED!!!! AHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!

[CerebrumMusica]

This is how the ratings should be. There should RARELY be a player rated 99. That means NO one can get better. 99 should basically be a perfect player, and there is no such thing. NBA2k gets this right. I'll keep an eye out on this and let me know if you want any help.

[Competitor]

Quote: Originally Posted by CerebrumMusica

This is how the ratings should be. There should RARELY be a player rated 99. That means NO one can get better. 99 should basically be a perfect player, and there is no such thing. NBA2k gets this right. I'll keep an eye out on this and let me know if you want any help.

That is exactly what I am trying to replicate. there really shouldn't be any 99 OVRs. that should be for the HOFs and stuff
I believe that when I am done that the highest OVR will be 95

[RedZoneD25]

Copycat. Just kidding. Good luck, it is a LOT of work.

[ambizytl]

I think you got QBs rated pretty accurate, no problems there for me. When you do rate RBs, remember that Arian Foster led the NFL in rushing, was second in catching for all RBs, led all RBs in receiving yards, and he made the Pro Bowl. Also, the game has his weight wrong, he is 227 pounds, not 215. You can check that on nfl.com and espn.com

Looking forward to seeing your roster.

And thanks!

[Competitor]

Quote: Originally Posted by WTFitsDaveyJ

Copycat. Just kidding. Good luck, it is a LOT of work.

dude trust me you were more than half of my inspiration to do this. I have always done this but really only to where it was so there wasn't many 90s but I feel that the only way to do this accurately is by doing all the players. I got through the QBs and half way through the RBs. I restarted the RBs because I finally got to them and I had a crap load of 90s still so I decided to make the ratings even lower.

Quote: Originally Posted by ambizytl

I think you got QBs rated pretty accurate, no problems there for me. When you do rate RBs, remember that Arian Foster led the NFL in rushing, was second in catching for all RBs, led all RBs in receiving yards, and he made the Pro Bowl. Also, the game has his weight wrong, he is 227 pounds, not 215. You can check that on nfl.com and espn.com Looking forward to seeing your roster. And thanks!

Yea I will definitely give Foster the deserved love ... I think I will give him the Top Rating

[ambizytl]

There are rookie RBs who never caught a pass in the NFL with much higher catch ratings than Foster. You have to sort by Catch and look at the ratings and compare to Foster who was second in receptions (RB) and led all RBs in receiving yardage, 604!

[Competitor]

Quote: Originally Posted by ambizytl

There are rookie RBs who never caught a pass in the NFL with much higher catch ratings than Foster. You have to sort by Catch and look at the ratings and compare to Foster who was second in receptions (RB) and led all RBs in receiving yardage, 604!

dude I understand that you are trying to put that Foster is a freakin beast but cmon if I give him really high ratings on all of those things then he will be a 99 or something but I will see what I can do.