on a scale of 1 through 10

[take-one-aday]

we've seen enough video to know how the final product of madden is gonna be like so on a scale of 1 to 10 how would you rate madden on;

presentation -
gameplay + gameflow -
Gus johnson commentary-
EA crew and their one year work on madden-

[RedZoneD25]

..no we haven't.

[CaliDude916]

5

[take-one-aday]

Quote: Originally Posted by davey225

..no we haven't.

^ go look at ign, gamestop, operationsports, g4, youtube, gametrailers; videos and comeback and post a respond

[take-one-aday]

presentation - 4; still needs more work, i dont think its better then NCAA
gameplay + gameflow - 3; same issue as last year
Gus johnson commentary- 2; slow, too many long pauses
EA crew and their one year work on madden - 2

[BlackJack_Williams]

ONLY based on what we've seen so far.

presentation - 7 (I do like what they're trying to do with presentation)
gameplay + gameflow - 0.5
Gus johnson commentary- 1 (He may have energy in his voice, still doesn't make it sound right)
EA crew and their one year work on madden- I won't judge this. Until I'm the man behind the scenes, I'll never really know how much effort they really put into this.

[PantherBeast_OS]

I will say aboout a 8 right now.

[beastsofboston]

Quote: Originally Posted by take-one-aday

^ go look at ign, gamestop, operationsports, g4, youtube, gametrailers; videos and comeback and post a respond

I agree with the original poster. Their has not been enough footage.