Perfect Commentary in a Sports Game

[madchuck4]

MLB 09 The Show! NUFF SAID! Madden should consider having the announcer from NCAA, he is WAY better than Hammond. But play MLB the show, the announcing is killer.

[Colladie]

Quote: Originally Posted by madchuck4

MLB 09 The Show! NUFF SAID! Madden should consider having the announcer from NCAA, he is WAY better than Hammond. But play MLB the show, the announcing is killer.

Though 2k9 is vastly inferior baseball game, it has better commentary than the show. Steve Philips frickin rocks in 2k.

[kwas676]

Yeah right its not perfect buts it is good, I'll put it up there with Live, MLB 2k9, and NCAA. Both Madden and NBA 2k9 need help.

[Jamin23]

Quote: Originally Posted by Colladie

Though 2k9 is vastly inferior baseball game, it has better commentary than the show. Steve Philips frickin rocks in 2k.

I agree although the show beats 2k in every other category except commentary and signature styles. The commentary is outstanding in 2k9 and other games should take note.

[metallidevils]

I love MLB The Show but the commentary is lacking. The phrases are sometimes long, and they never interrupt themselves, so they are sometimes behind in the action by a few seconds. NHL 09, however, is nearly flawless in that regard. For such a fast paced game, commentary is spot on.

[mars85042]

allpro 2k8 also has great commentary...

[Clarke_311]

I like the commentary in MLB 09, it sounds like they're calling a real baseball game. MLB 2K9 has the edge, though, but they're both very good. If Madden can make their commentary like either of these games the commentary will be good.

[MattIntellect]

Quote: Originally Posted by madchuck4

MLB 09 The Show! NUFF SAID! Madden should consider having the announcer from NCAA, he is WAY better than Hammond. But play MLB the show, the announcing is killer.

The announcer from NCAA doesn't cover the NFL, he covers NCAA. This would definitely not be authentic and will never happen.