More Links

Flo · 03-25-2009, 11:20 PM

I can't get the Madden team to answer this question, so I assume the answer to be "NO", but I figured I would try here. Will NCAA 10 (or Madden 10) finally be 1080p for the PS3 like it has been for the Xbox360?

As I said, I assume we PS3 owners are getting screwed again, but I might as well ask. It isn't like they don't know the answer. If they can't program for the PS3 properly, I wish they would drop the platform instead of ripping us off year after year.

Any EA guys here that want to step up and answer the question?

Flo

BSherrod · 03-26-2009, 12:19 AM

It's not as easy as it sounds. The 360 is 720p as well, but it has a hardware scaler that puts all games at up to 1080p resolution.

gschwendt · 03-26-2009, 12:33 AM

The answer is 99.9999999% no and will likely be that answer this entire generation of consoles. They are stressing the systems enough as it is trying to push 720 lines at 60 frames per second. If they ever get to 1080p it will likely be because they dropped down to 30fps (very unlikely) or they take a huge hit in the graphics department (very very unlikely).

That or they just finally unlock the secret code behind programming for the PS3... it's not up up down down left right left right b a start... I already tried that one.

Madwolf · 03-26-2009, 03:08 AM

It's not that the PS3 can't handle it, or that you have to decrease the framerate to make it run at that level on the PS3.

The truth is the game runs at 720 on both systems, the 360 just has a built in upscaler to run the game at 1080. It's not a true 1080, and that's 100% the facts.

No the speculation. When I learned of this I'm pretty sure they said that the 360 didn't have the fanciest upscaler in the world, but they wanted to have one. Sony on the other hand didn't want people to upscale games on their system, but through upscalers in TVs themselves, which is apparently part of the new designs, and according to Sony have higher quality upscalers in them than the 360.

dave374 · 03-26-2009, 03:29 AM

It's unlikely.
The ps3 version is simply a 360 port ... and I suspect EA programmers don't have a ton of time to get it right for the ps3.
You could slam EA, but the 360 does outsell the ps3 and there's no chance in hell you will ever see separate development teams. The economy is just too brutal for that, and even if it wasn't, I doubt a company would use two teams for a game.

Flo · 03-29-2009, 10:27 PM

Thanks to all who responded. I don't believe it is overworking the PS3 to make it 1080p. That is absurd. I do believe that EA doesn't give a rodents hindquarters about Sony users, even though the PS1 is what made this game, and Madden as well.

It is a matter of business. Cater to the Micro$oft people to make a buck and screw the PS3 people. Great. Why not just drop the platform? People that want to play Madden can buy and XboX. It didn't seem to hurt Gears or Halo to be Micro$oft only.

Constantly screwing part of your customer base is bad business. Even worse is the fact that not one EA guy from NCAA or Madden will step up to the plate and give an answer as to why. Heck, they won't even come forth and say it will be 720. I guess EA didn't issue backbones to their guys.

Again, thanks to the guys to who responded.

Flo

stoncold32 · 03-29-2009, 11:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Flo


	Thanks to all who responded. I don't believe it is overworking the PS3 to make it 1080p. That is absurd. I do believe that EA doesn't give a rodents hindquarters about Sony users, even though the PS1 is what made this game, and Madden as well. It is a matter of business. Cater to the Micro$oft people to make a buck and screw the PS3 people. Great. Why not just drop the platform? People that want to play Madden can buy and XboX. It didn't seem to hurt Gears or Halo to be Micro$oft only. Constantly screwing part of your customer base is bad business. Even worse is the fact that not one EA guy from NCAA or Madden will step up to the plate and give an answer as to why. Heck, they won't even come forth and say it will be 720. I guess EA didn't issue backbones to their guys. Again, thanks to the guys to who responded. Flo

I personally think it sucks. My 360 died right before this game came out last year, and I switched to a PS3. I had already downloaded the 09 demo on 360, and it looked really good. I got the final PS3 version, and I could immediately tell the difference in the graphics. Ticked me off to be honest....especially when FIFA plays in 1080P.

mercalnd · 03-30-2009, 04:52 PM

As others have stated, both versions are 720p but it's the 360 that upscales its games. So the games have exactly the same graphical content and both run at 720p. So the difference is really only in whether your system or your TV upscales the graphics to 1080p, which is pretty much moot unless your TV doesn't upscale well.

03-25-2009, 11:20 PM	#1
Flo Rookie OVR: 2 Join Date: Aug 2008	NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3? I can't get the Madden team to answer this question, so I assume the answer to be "NO", but I figured I would try here. Will NCAA 10 (or Madden 10) finally be 1080p for the PS3 like it has been for the Xbox360? As I said, I assume we PS3 owners are getting screwed again, but I might as well ask. It isn't like they don't know the answer. If they can't program for the PS3 properly, I wish they would drop the platform instead of ripping us off year after year. Any EA guys here that want to step up and answer the question? Flo

03-26-2009, 12:19 AM	#2
BSherrod Rookie OVR: 9 Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: Tuscaloosa	Re: NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3? It's not as easy as it sounds. The 360 is 720p as well, but it has a hardware scaler that puts all games at up to 1080p resolution. __________________ Roll Tide

03-26-2009, 12:33 AM	#3
gschwendt EA Game Changer OVR: 12 Join Date: May 2003 Location: Little Rock, AR	Re: NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3? The answer is 99.9999999% no and will likely be that answer this entire generation of consoles. They are stressing the systems enough as it is trying to push 720 lines at 60 frames per second. If they ever get to 1080p it will likely be because they dropped down to 30fps (very unlikely) or they take a huge hit in the graphics department (very very unlikely). That or they just finally unlock the secret code behind programming for the PS3... it's not up up down down left right left right b a start... I already tried that one.

03-26-2009, 03:08 AM	#4
Madwolf MVP OVR: 9 Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: Louisville, KY	Re: NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3? It's not that the PS3 can't handle it, or that you have to decrease the framerate to make it run at that level on the PS3. The truth is the game runs at 720 on both systems, the 360 just has a built in upscaler to run the game at 1080. It's not a true 1080, and that's 100% the facts. No the speculation. When I learned of this I'm pretty sure they said that the 360 didn't have the fanciest upscaler in the world, but they wanted to have one. Sony on the other hand didn't want people to upscale games on their system, but through upscalers in TVs themselves, which is apparently part of the new designs, and according to Sony have higher quality upscalers in them than the 360.

03-26-2009, 03:29 AM	#5
dave374 Banned OVR: 24 Join Date: Feb 2003	Re: NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3? It's unlikely. The ps3 version is simply a 360 port ... and I suspect EA programmers don't have a ton of time to get it right for the ps3. You could slam EA, but the 360 does outsell the ps3 and there's no chance in hell you will ever see separate development teams. The economy is just too brutal for that, and even if it wasn't, I doubt a company would use two teams for a game.

	New OS Forums Are Coming on May 1
	The Best Sports Gaming Year of All-Time
	Arcade Sports Games Need a Revival

03-29-2009, 10:27 PM	#6
Flo Rookie OVR: 2 Join Date: Aug 2008	Re: NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3? Thanks to all who responded. I don't believe it is overworking the PS3 to make it 1080p. That is absurd. I do believe that EA doesn't give a rodents hindquarters about Sony users, even though the PS1 is what made this game, and Madden as well. It is a matter of business. Cater to the Micro$oft people to make a buck and screw the PS3 people. Great. Why not just drop the platform? People that want to play Madden can buy and XboX. It didn't seem to hurt Gears or Halo to be Micro$oft only. Constantly screwing part of your customer base is bad business. Even worse is the fact that not one EA guy from NCAA or Madden will step up to the plate and give an answer as to why. Heck, they won't even come forth and say it will be 720. I guess EA didn't issue backbones to their guys. Again, thanks to the guys to who responded. Flo

03-30-2009, 04:52 PM	#8
mercalnd MVP OVR: 18 Join Date: Oct 2004 Posts: 4,267	Re: NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3? As others have stated, both versions are 720p but it's the 360 that upscales its games. So the games have exactly the same graphical content and both run at 720p. So the difference is really only in whether your system or your TV upscales the graphics to 1080p, which is pretty much moot unless your TV doesn't upscale well.

More Links

NCAA 10 - 1080p on PS3?