Top 10 Players at Each Position in MLB The Show 17

[zman2392]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jaysguy44

Dude you made a good argument but you fail in choose who's better which is obviously Donalson . Machado is a little vagina and did you watch the WBC game where Arenado blew it for the US with his bonehead throw to first?..no thank you..can't handle pressure...so yeah Donalson wins again as usual go Jays!!

While I don't condone the language... Or necessarily agree with much of this... I may kind of agree with one part.

[douggoud]

And I'd take Mike Trout over all of them

[Mitchrapp]

Imo, the 1st baseman's are rated a bit low..

[Blazzen]

Wonder where Ender Inciarte ends up. Maybe tied with Odubel Hererra at an 82? Or maybe just below that?

Odubel has more pop but Ender won a gold glove. He can't be too far behind.

[xCULLO]

They're definitely over rating players that don't a lot of PT.. Like Sanchez and Turner. Turner I get to a certain extent but for someone to never play the position in the Majors and be the 3rd highest rated player at that position is ridiculous to me. and Sanchez was the hottest player on Earth right when he got promoted.. *cough *cough Yasiel Puig.. Corey Seager earned that 90 overall with one of the best rookie campaigns at SS of all time.

[Dillow]

*An obligatory post about how my player on my team is rated too low and a player on a rival team is rated too high*

Next week cant get here fast enough though for real.

[TattooedEvil]

Quote: Originally Posted by xCULLO

They're definitely over rating players that don't a lot of PT.. Like Sanchez and Turner. Turner I get to a certain extent but for someone to never play the position in the Majors and be the 3rd highest rated player at that position is ridiculous to me. and Sanchez was the hottest player on Earth right when he got promoted.. *cough *cough Yasiel Puig.. Corey Seager earned that 90 overall with one of the best rookie campaigns at SS of all time.

ya i really dont get how u get a 88 at a position u dont even touch. Apparently a cup of coffee in the MLB at CF means ur as good as BCraw at SS? As long as Crawford is 95+ across the board at defensive attributes im good with the 88 tho even tho he's proved himself wayyyy longer then everyone but Tulo on that list.

[gradek87]

32 live series diamonds and another 12 at 88-89. Going to be interesting how insider edge changes ratings because we would end up with a ton of live series diamonds this year (already up 25% over last year). Greatly reduces the odds of getting any specific one (and greatly reducing the supply for each as well) and makes the collection missions much harder.