Madden NFL 17 Title Update #7 Available Now, Here Are The Details

[swanklax]

Quote: Originally Posted by Charvalos

26 completions for 324 yards ? Personnally, for a backup (66 OVR), I don't really think is realistic. For a QB like Brady, Big Ben, maybe Tolzien, against the Steelers last week, finished the game with 22/36, 205 yds. And, it was against the Steelers defense.. And like some people said, how many miss throws did you see ?

It's really silly to evaluate the performance of anything on a one game sample size. Here's a non-exhaustive list of bad quarterbacks who have thrown for 400+ yards in a game:

Matt Schaub
Josh McCown
Kellen Moore (!!!!)
Nick Foles
Josh Freeman
Matt Cassel
Kyle Orton
Matt Flynn
Matt Leinart
Chris Weike

You can only imagine how many bad quarterbacks have thrown for 300+ yards, especially on 43 attempts. With the right sliders, the QBA isn't a huge deal.

[redsox4evur]

Quote: Originally Posted by Charvalos

26 completions for 324 yards ? Personnally, for a backup (66 OVR), I don't really think is realistic. For a QB like Brady, Big Ben, maybe Tolzien, against the Steelers last week, finished the game with 22/36, 205 yds. And, it was against the Steelers defense.. And like some people said, how many miss throws did you see ?

I saw a lot of missed throws. Especially with me using Ryan Fitzpatrick. Just did another gameplan for this week and he missed like 2-3 throws.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JoshC1977]

Quote: Originally Posted by ehh

I am glad to hear that some aren't having an issue. I tried your set a few weeks back and the CPU scored one TD in four games against my average defense. Unfortunately that set isn't for me unless using preseason rosters is some magical difference maker.

Well, I posted updates on 11/20/2016; and if you were using my previous iteration, that outcome wouldn't totally shock me.

That said, as well all know, no slider set is "one size fits all".

[ehh]

Quote: Originally Posted by JoshC1977

Well, I posted updates on 11/20/2016; and if you were using my previous iteration, that outcome wouldn't totally shock me. That said, as well all know, no slider set is "one size fits all".

Cool, I'll try them out this weekend.

[Smallville102001]

Quote: Originally Posted by swanklax

It's really silly to evaluate the performance of anything on a one game sample size. Here's a non-exhaustive list of bad quarterbacks who have thrown for 400+ yards in a game: Matt Schaub Josh McCown Kellen Moore (!!!!) Nick Foles Josh Freeman Matt Cassel Kyle Orton Matt Flynn Matt Leinart Chris Weike You can only imagine how many bad quarterbacks have thrown for 300+ yards, especially on 43 attempts. With the right sliders, the QBA isn't a huge deal.

A few of those QB I don't think are bad and yes one game you cant judge because yes even bad players can have good games but before we had a single patch this year I was seeing 55-70% most games with a few games where CPU would be 50 or lower and a few games where CPU would be like 75-80 and I was seeing bad passes and playing a top QB like Brady felt much different then playing some bad QB. After the October patch that went away to the point where just about ever game is 70-80% and about the only way a ball is incomplete is if WR drops pass or QB throws it away or defender hits the ball and playing a top QB vs a ok QB doesn't fell that different.

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Smallville102001

A few of those QB I don't think are bad and yes one game you cant judge because yes even bad players can have good games but before we had a single patch this year I was seeing 55-70% most games with a few games where CPU would be 50 or lower and a few games where CPU would be like 75-80 and I was seeing bad passes and playing a top QB like Brady felt much different then playing some bad QB. After the October patch that went away to the point where just about ever game is 70-80% and about the only way a ball is incomplete is if WR drops pass or QB throws it away or defender hits the ball and playing a top QB vs a ok QB doesn't fell that different.

It's interesting people are getting different results with the same game. That tells me no two players are the same.

I don't have a complaint on the QBA, but I know others are having issues with it.

[Sturzinator]

Quote: Originally Posted by swanklax

It's really silly to evaluate the performance of anything on a one game sample size. Here's a non-exhaustive list of bad quarterbacks who have thrown for 400+ yards in a game: Matt Schaub Josh McCown Kellen Moore (!!!!) Nick Foles Josh Freeman Matt Cassel Kyle Orton Matt Flynn Matt Leinart Chris Weike You can only imagine how many bad quarterbacks have thrown for 300+ yards, especially on 43 attempts. With the right sliders, the QBA isn't a huge deal.

It's equally silly to throw out a few names of mediocre QBs that have had career games over the course of years in the league to attempt to rationalize what is clearly a consistent (game to game) issue for many M17 gamers.

I could match your list on a 3 or 4 to one basis of those same QBs and many others having horrible games.

The bottom line is you can probably statistically rationalize just about anything if you dig deep enough through the annals of a league with decades of game logs, but that does not excuse what is a chronic issue with the QB play in this series (not just M17).

I am not experiencing the extremes of what some are seeing with regard to the accuracy, but I am not using a community slider set. I do see where there is a problem though. One thing I do see, that a find very irksome, is that whenever it happens I injure the CPU starting QB, the back up comes in and invariably plays lights out. Often times, in fact, better than the starter he replaced.

With all the insidious and outwardly innocuous settings (main menu settings, auto subs, etc) that singly or in combination can alter the gameplay so drastically it's no wonder there's no easy solution. I am sure there are as yet undiscovered settings that are unwittingly affecting the game play in some fashion as well.

There's a reason why EA has never come out and stated what exactly the sliders do or how to use them to remedy the effects were reporting because they have no idea themselves. Speaking out would only cause them further embarrassment.

I am not hopeful there will be a solution to this or the many other legacy issues that stubbornly remain in full glory in M17 until there is a complete rebuild or the door is re-opened for competitors' offerings.

[newguy27]

Is the current running game really that much worse compared to the day one release without patches?