Madden NFL 17 Player Ratings- Top 5 Cornerbacks

[charter04]

I guess I'm just not as impressed with Josh Norman than others are. Seems to be more of a system guy. Not sayings he's bad but, I like Pat Pet the best.

[kehlis]

Quote: Originally Posted by Blazzen

Josh Norman is good, but not the best. That distinction belongs to Patrick Peterson ESPECIALLY when you consider Peterson is also a great punt returner.

What does being a good punt returner have to do with being a good cornerback?

[Dcooks]

Pat Pete makes too many mistakes and gets the business too much against the top wrs. Im sorry, he overrated. Great athleticism. Gets a lot of hype for holding the top men, but is getting beat quite often by them. Chris Harris after what AB did to him should be number 5 at best. Sherman could get a little more respect. Norman earned that top spot. Revis aint the same as he was, but deserves to be top 4.

[seasprite]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

What does being a good punt returner have to do with being a good cornerback?

If that were the case, Cordarrelle Patterson would be considered a great WR

[stocksy]

Phew. Seeing all these Top 5 lists I was starting to worry that EA hadn't got the rights to the feature the Jets..


Apparently they are in after all

[solmon]

Peters will be on this list as the season progresses. Think Sherman and Revis will slide a bit. Norman being number 1 a little surprising...but not really sure who is clear number 1 anymore.

[Vollin]

Quote: Originally Posted by seasprite

If that were the case, Cordarrelle Patterson would be considered a great WR

Patterson is a great WR. GBO.

[extremeskins04]

This list confuses me badly. I love the Redskins as I'm originally from Washington DC, but how is Josh Norman #1 over Peterson, Revis, Haden, Sherman?

I'm really confused.

Also, what about Chris Harris, Jason Verrett?