Madden NFL 17 Address All 3 Phases of the Game: Offense, Defense & Special Teams

[JayhawkerStL]

Quote: Originally Posted by TheShizNo1

Nah, man. I've had instances in which my WRs feet are clearly in bounds, it's cancan't call for oneled incomplete, and I'm unable to challenge. Or I can, and it's still in complete. Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk

Good thing that never happens in real life.

Seriously, they should actually just dump replay, because I don't think gamers can handle it. Yes, I've seen blown replays.

Oh, and you can't call replays in the late in halves either.

It's not broken. Or I'm the luckiest guy in the world, and the people I've played online that complained tend to be the only ones that don't understand. Because, yeah, I've seen people complain.

I saw a guy try to challenge a fumble this morning. He was pissed because he could challenge, yet earlier I won a review I didn't even call for.

[Lexicon]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jay D

Good thing that never happens in real life. Seriously, they should actually just dump replay, because I don't think gamers can handle it. Yes, I've seen blown replays. Oh, and you can't call replays in the late in halves either. It's not broken. Or I'm the luckiest guy in the world, and the people I've played online that complained tend to be the only ones that don't understand. Because, yeah, I've seen people complain. I saw a guy try to challenge a fumble this morning. He was pissed because he could challenge, yet earlier I won a review I didn't even call for.

You're the luckiest guy in the world.

[howboutdat]

Quote: Originally Posted by Lexicon

You're the luckiest guy in the world.

for sure he is

[DeuceDouglas]

I think the game has trouble with a lot of the rules as well especially when it comes to catches. Obviously this is a tough one but this was from a game I played where this pretty clearly shouldn't have even been a catch but was ruled a catch and fumble, reviewed and stood as such.

[SolidSquid]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jay D

Good thing that never happens in real life. Seriously, they should actually just dump replay, because I don't think gamers can handle it. Yes, I've seen blown replays. Oh, and you can't call replays in the late in halves either. It's not broken. Or I'm the luckiest guy in the world, and the people I've played online that complained tend to be the only ones that don't understand. Because, yeah, I've seen people complain. I saw a guy try to challenge a fumble this morning. He was pissed because he could challenge, yet earlier I won a review I didn't even call for.

It's broken man just accept it. Just yesterday Mike Evans got both feet down, it was ruled incomplete so I challenged. They review it and say the play on field is overturned, but it's still second and ten.

[SageInfinite]

Quote: Originally Posted by DeuceDouglas

I think the game has trouble with a lot of the rules as well especially when it comes to catches. Obviously this is a tough one but this was from a game I played where this pretty clearly shouldn't have even been a catch but was ruled a catch and fumble, reviewed and stood as such.

Like I stated, every once in awhile on a close play, I'm not going to complain, it happens in real life, but some of the calls are just ridiculous.

Good post.

[OhMrHanky]

Quote: Originally Posted by CM Hooe

Yeah the challenge mechanics are quite easily far behind anything else in the game. Not sure they've significantly changed since they were first introduced on the... PS2?

I think they have improved over the last few years with 16 being the best, yet. Perfect? NO. Lol. But, I remember 13, 25, and 15 having problems constantly with challenge errors. But, for me, in 16, I would say I agree with about 80% of the calls/challenges that happen. I have even won a challenge or 2 that I called that reversed a TD. Today, I recovered a fumble from CPU. I looked at the replay, and said, 'damn. He hit the ground before he fumbled. This will get reversed.' I unpause the game, and sure enough, 'the previous play is being reviewed.' And, sure enough, it was reversed. But, I have def also seen the one foot in bounds called a catch. And, 2 feet in bounds called incomplete. So, again, for me, it's not perfect, but I can def tell improvements were made to the logic in 16, and I don't feel completely cheated when challenges occur (or, when they don't let me challenge - again, yes, this happens, but not enough in my games to overly concern me). You would think that based on the fact it is a vid game, they should be able to detect every little thing, but honestly, when 'mistakes' occur, for me, I can actually chalk it up to 'human error' for reality sake. How many replays have u seen challenged in real life where u said to yourself, 'get out of here, man!!!! What???!!!!' So, I can play it off that way. In some ways, that makes it more realistic. Lol

[avwhitechic]

You always bring it.