Madden NFL 16 Player Ratings - Top 6 Quarterbacks

[charter04]

The list seems fine. Not much difference between 99-90 really.

It's good to see that 80 is the highest TAD.

Hopefully they make all throws less pinpoint and hopefully your feet must be set to use the full accuracy rating.

Also I hope the accuracy slider works like they should and I don't have to go to 10 or below before I really see a difference.

Hopefully all sliders work as they should for that matter. They haven't since M13.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[slowdifference]

If i had to rate top 10 qb's
1: Rodgers 98
2: Brady 96
3: P Manning 95
4: Luck 93
5: Brees 93
6: Big Ben 92
7: Romo 91
8: Wilson 91
9: Rivers 90
10: Flacco/Ryan 89

[The JareBear]

I have no issue with manning dropping of the top 5. I've watched every game he's played in a Broncos uniform. The guy is amazing but at this point there are just a lot of throws he can't physically make.

[ChaseB]

Quote: Originally Posted by MelR2000

Guess who had the best QBR last season ?That would be Tony Romo .

Quote: Originally Posted by Batum Shaka Laka

Romo's absence is a joke - he's treated differently year to year than everyone else is. As a longtime Pac 12 (10) fan there's no way Luck deserves a 95 throw power. 91 tops

Quote: Originally Posted by talucchesi

Romo better be sixth here. Perception is truly reality when it comes to sports. Not quite sure how Big Ben is ahead of him, living off of his rings I see. I can see Peyton being over Romo, I'd accept that.

Quote: Originally Posted by Letemburn

Romo had highest qb rating last year and was excellent. No way Big Ben deserves too 5 over Romo.

Roethlisberger is playing better now than he did when he was winning those rings, for what it's worth. The offense has changed and he's throwing way more as well. Pittsburgh also had the best pass offense in the NFL last year by DVOA.

I'm a Romo fan, but let's not just push by the fact that Romo had the third best rushing offense by DVOA last year and arguably the best offensive line as well. He got a chance to put up more efficient numbers because the Cowboys finally ran the proper offense and got him protection. Romo's lack of clutch stats and "choking" and all that are mostly fiction, so again, I'm defending the guy overall, but let's be reasonable at the same time.

Andrew Luck meanwhile had a bad offensive line, takes more hits than seems possible, had a rushing offense ranked 27th by DVOA and still put together an impressive year for a guy still on his rookie contract.

Quote: Originally Posted by JKSportsGamer1984

Luck is a little overrated. Not sure if he's top 5 just yet. Still throws too many pics. On the other hand, Russell Wilson is severely underrated smh. Not saying he's top 5 but he's close. His awareness is arguably the best in the league.

I like Wilson a lot, but I hope you're not saying you would take Russ over Luck. Wilson is part of the best rushing attack in the NFL, Luck is the entire offense for the Colts.

[Steve_OS]

Romo is #6 with an overall 93 rating. I'll update the OP in a few.

http://www.nfl.com/photos/0ap3000000503127

[iLLWiLL]

Quote: Originally Posted by Steve_OS

Romo is #6 with an overall 93 rating. I'll update the OP in a few.

Graphics look amazing. Although the issue of the shoulder pads not being their own entity really rears its ugly head in this pic: that over-stretched stripe is an eye sore


Back on topic -- I wish they would just release the top 10 ...

[talucchesi]

Quote: Originally Posted by ChaseB

Roethlisberger is playing better now than he did when he was winning those rings, for what it's worth. The offense has changed and he's throwing way more as well. Pittsburgh also had the best pass offense in the NFL last year by DVOA. I'm a Romo fan, but let's not just push by the fact that Romo had the third best rushing offense by DVOA last year and arguably the best offensive line as well. He got a chance to put up more efficient numbers because the Cowboys finally ran the proper offense and got him protection. Romo's lack of clutch stats and "choking" and all that are mostly fiction, so again, I'm defending the guy overall, but let's be reasonable at the same time. Andrew Luck meanwhile had a bad offensive line, takes more hits than seems possible, had a rushing offense ranked 27th by DVOA and still put together an impressive year for a guy still on his rookie contract. I like Wilson a lot, but I hope you're not saying you would take Russ over Luck. Wilson is part of the best rushing attack in the NFL, Luck is the entire offense for the Colts.

I like your points alot, but my only counter argument to this is find me a more consistent QB from year than year outside the 4 elite QB's than Romo. This and one of the Barber/Jones/Choice years are the two only years Romo wasn't asketd to throw 40+ times every game. This was the only year Romo had solid protection nearly every game

Even then, he makes the Oline look that much better with the amount of people he makes miss, same can be said the Big Ben though

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by jshake8

So is what you posted how you would have them rated in Madden? When Madden comes out, will Brady be in the top 5?

I don't know. We will have to see how things shake out before then.