For Better or Worse, The Show is in the Details

[HenryClay1844]

I'm only casually interested in baseball and have found the gameplay mechanics of the show frustrating (being able to actually get hits while playing on a challenging level), but as someone who's number one game is soccer and FIFA I so envy the depth and attention to detail in the show. The visual presentation (not the audio) and the attention to detail for rules and depth of experience for franchise blows FIFA out of the water. I also love the transparency of promotion for the Show to the managed snippets EA gives us for FIFA.

[mosdef328]

Quote: Originally Posted by Armor & Sword

I am a baseball player and travel coach first and foremost. With that angle it is so easy for me to appreciate MLB The Show year in and year out. Because on the field they have consistently out done the previous version with so many little things. 1. Ball physics - The single most important and evolving feature IMO. The game has felt more and more real to me because of the way the ball behaves. It looks and feels very realistic. I play ball almost every day (yeah still do it oh my aching muscles!). This part of the game keeps me coming back for more. Hit variety has gotten better and better since MLB 11 and then on 12 with the introduction of ball physics 1.0 2. Batter/Pitcher showdown - the heart and soul of any console baseball game. MLB The Show nailed this and continues to nail this aspect. Baseball is the ultimate game of anticipation. Nothing is better than facing down a big stick and getting them to chase a pitch low and away for a huge strike out. Nothing get's me more pumped than than having my best hitter at the plate, down 0-2 in the count and working it back to 3-2 and then launching a HR into the bleachers. This part of the game is supreme. No game does it better than The Show. 3. Atmosphere - every year it's get's better and better and better. 4. Controls/interfaces/options - The ultimate game of options and finding a combo you love to play with. Is there any sports game that has built upon their foundation of control options like The Show? This season we are getting a host of franchise improvements with the trade finder, contract handbook, radio show, better broadcast aspects, well over a 1000 new lines of play by play, GM goals...they keep making an already rich and deep franchise mode even better. In a nutshell this team understands how to keep it's core intact and build out a game. Adding layers to already successful layers. Great communication and responsiveness to their hard core fans. What more could you want. Well OK...closing roofs and historical stats (important aspects of baseball big time)....and I know we will get it all this console cycle. I know they will keep enhancing and improving an already AAA title. 12 more days!!!!

Love your comments and appreciate your expert insight. I just started playing the Show last year on PS4. I love baseball and think the team does a great job capturing the atmosphere of the game.

[dazzelle]

Few of the little things i have liked so far.

I really liked how the lighting changed in the final game with nick and kirby, never noticed it change like that in any of the other games so maybe it needs those specific settings(think it was partly cloudy),would love a random/dynamic weather setting.

I also liked the replay when kirby hit a 3 run dbl and how camera stayed showing the whole field instead of cutting to the ball quickly like normal.So excited that there maybe more improvements with replays/replay angles.

And agree HenryClay about the devs showing off the game,TBH i think i enjoyed listening to them talk about the game and stuff more than seeing the gameplay,still glad they showed it though.

[xCULLO]

I would buy The Show every year if they just changed the cover of the box, I'm as die-hard as it gets.

As they said in one of the live streams, baseball is one of the few sports that rely on little things to determine the outcome of games, seasons, and careers. It is only fitting that they continue to improve on the "little things" that make this sport as great as it is.

[rkf0901]

I wish EA's NHL team would put this much into their product.

[brrmikey]

The thread is right on point. The Show is a solid game year after year. The other day I asked myself what does this game do year after year to make me not EVER remotely even think about playing the previous version(s)...and this is coming from a player who only uses offline single season & playoff modes, nothing else. it dawned on me that it has to be all the little things adding up to a better game year after year.

[Jr.]

I still feel the game is too scripted at times, but I do feel the game comes pretty close to replicating baseball well.

I would just like to see more misplayed balls in the OF, different error animations, and throws that are more random. I haven't noticed the new tag system in any of the videos I've watched so far, so I'm still interested to see how that plays out, too.

I'm pumped for the changes with contracts and the offseason, though. Should make it much more realistic when putting a team together.

[DGuinta1]

I hope they improve the Play by Play. Love how it's done with NBA2k15.