MLB 15 The Show Has New Human IK Engine, Tag System, Commentary, Overhauled Franchise

[Blzer]

Quote: Originally Posted by nemesis04

They have recorded actual on field sound a few years back for this type stuff.

They did, which makes this all the more unfortunate (because normally that means they won't be addressed again for a while). But sometimes things don't translate right. Maybe it's a different mic, maybe it's on a sound stage instead of on a field, maybe they used a different bat, maybe they hit it off a tee, maybe it was hit by a developer and not a pro, maybe they didn't account for all hit types. For the most part, you really only hear just a few sounds, and the bat can have millions of different sounds. Even some players have a different kind of "explosion" when they hit it.

A bit off-topic, but it's like when I hear a player goes in and does his own mo-cap, say Buster Posey in 2011 or whatever year. Just because he went in and did it doesn't mean his stance was actually accurate. I watch him bat like 500 times a year, I'm not going to be placebo'd by the fact that somebody tells me who did what. Low and behold, it was bettered the next year. Apparently he just didn't do his own stance right, lol.

[aguero90]

Sometimes when I go to a Yanks game, I bring a digital recorder, and it picks up all the baseball sounds. I just played it back now, and bat on ball sounds just like ASB series did. So I don't know what they did back then, but they nailed it!

[Jimmydm90]

Quote: Originally Posted by aguero90

Sometimes when I go to a Yanks game, I bring a digital recorder, and it picks up all the baseball sounds. I just played it back now, and bat on ball sounds just like ASB series did. So I don't know what they did back then, but they nailed it!

An Everyman casually recording sounds at a big public event. All you need is to record something you shouldn't have, something dangerous and you've got yourself the beginnings of a Hitchcock movie.

[aguero90]

hahahaha! I think I'll take it to old timers day! After all, I'll be sitting in the front row behind the plate, and you never know what kind of big stars will be sitting near me... Maybe I can get someone famous on record!! I'll bring my cane, and take off my glasses, and make sure I have a pen and things for signing! Gotta milk it!

[seanjeezy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Blzer

They did, which makes this all the more unfortunate (because normally that means they won't be addressed again for a while). But sometimes things don't translate right. Maybe it's a different mic, maybe it's on a sound stage instead of on a field, maybe they used a different bat, maybe they hit it off a tee, maybe it was hit by a developer and not a pro, maybe they didn't account for all hit types. For the most part, you really only hear just a few sounds, and the bat can have millions of different sounds. Even some players have a different kind of "explosion" when they hit it. A bit off-topic, but it's like when I hear a player goes in and does his own mo-cap, say Buster Posey in 2011 or whatever year. Just because he went in and did it doesn't mean his stance was actually accurate. I watch him bat like 500 times a year, I'm not going to be placebo'd by the fact that somebody tells me who did what. Low and behold, it was bettered the next year. Apparently he just didn't do his own stance right, lol.

I know its for 2K but your point still stands. There is actually a comparison starting at 2:04

Feliz has a pretty low effort delivery but his mocap is exceptionally low effort, almost like he's practicing pfp's lol

[Woodweaver]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jimmydm90

An Everyman casually recording sounds at a big public event. All you need is to record something you shouldn't have, something dangerous and you've got yourself the beginnings of a Hitchcock movie.

..or a sweet '80s Travolta movie.

[Jimmydm90]

Quote: Originally Posted by Woodweaver

..or a sweet '80s Travolta movie.

Haha Depalma was definitely inspired by Hitchcock when he made Blow Out.

[Stolm]

Quote: Originally Posted by aguero90

Every time I play the show, I think to myself that the sound of bat on ball really needs an upgrade! It just doesn't sound solid enough, not like a real bat on ball makes. I especially can tell the difference, because my hearing is unbelievable, (that saying about other senses being better when you lack one is true!) As it stands now, the sound is very "crcked bat sounding." not, "solid wood sound." Listen to a real life sound, then hear the show, and you'll see what I mean.

Agreed. Even on a big home theatre system the sound off the bat sounds weak.

The sound isn't deep enough.