NBA 2K15 Fact or Fiction: Is NBA 2K15's Gameplay the Best in Sports Gaming?

[Boilerbuzz]

No disrespect to personal opinions and especially experiences. If people want to talk about Show and PES in it s heyday. Cool. Even FIFA gets some credit. But this Madden talk? Although it is LESS maddening (no pun intended) than years past, if you think that game come within a block of real football, the your depth of knowledge of football is in kiddy wading pool. Sorry. I'm not saying the game isn't fun and in many ways is a fun interpretation of football. But I want the depth of a true sim. Madden is too far away from that at this time.

[xzcxzcxvcxv]

You can doubt their servers, but no one can say they don't have the BEST gameplay of any sports game.

[HarrySTruman]

I think NBA 2k15 is best in class, but the gap is narrowing! MLB the Show is terrific, and Madden made great strides this year. FIFA is always a class act, but I didn't feel it improved all that much from last year to this. NHL 15 is great on the ice, but the modes really need work; some of them went backwards this year. For me it's a close call between NBA and the Show, especially as baseball is my favorite sport, but I find NBA 2K15 a bit more compelling.