Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC East

[A_Quiet_Pro]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

I live in Pittsburgh, not from here....

Gotcha. So are you a Broncos fan?

[kehlis]

Quote: Originally Posted by SiNsinNatti

I didn't make an assumption someone else did. I just asked if you thought Polamalu was overrated. To see where you stand... I answered your pro bowl question you're the one ignoring what I said... Finished ignoring fact?

No you didn't, I asked if you would consider Bailey a perennial pro bowler. You responded to that with a question, not an answer.

Entire point being you can't use pro bowl status to argue someone should be rated in the 90's which you previously agreed to by admitting Champ shouldn't be rated that high.

Works the same whether it's your favorite team or not.

[SiNsinNatti]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

No you didn't, I asked if you would consider Bailey a perennial pro bowler. You responded to that with a question, not an answer. Entire point being you can't use pro bowl status to argue someone should be rated in the 90's which you previously agreed to by admitting Champ shouldn't be rated that high. Works the same whether it's your favorite team or not.

Smh. Go back two pages I already agreed to the pro bowl. That's why I mentioned him coming off a ALL PRO season. I acknowledged that fans do vote for it so I turned the focus to his actual play and ALL PRO season.

[kehlis]

Quote: Originally Posted by SiNsinNatti

Smh. Go back two pages I already agreed to the pro bowl. That's why I mentioned him coming off a ALL PRO season. I acknowledged that fans do vote for it so I turned the focus to his actual play and ALL PRO season.

No need to shake your head, I saw that post as well.

So Champ Bailey is also what you would describe as a perennial All Pro.

Does he deserve a rating over 90 because of that? That was your argument, not mine.

[Senor_Herbatron]

It seems like Miami should have a pretty decent team this year.

[SiNsinNatti]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

No need to shake your head, I saw that post as well. So Champ Bailey is also what you would describe as a perennial All Pro. Does he deserve a rating over 90 because of that? That was your argument, not mine.

Smh even more. Clearly stated I feel he should be higher rate based on his play last season which is what these ratings are based on. You're taking one word I said and since rephrased, to heart. Rolle out played a lot of the people rated higher than him. Doesn't both me that much just pointing it how it's flawed to me. Rolle's 100 tackles 6 picks = 86 Polamalu's 50 tackles & 2 picks equal 93.

[atom27]

First post! Hi all.

Getting back into Madden after a 5 year layoff, and came here to check out ratings and stuff. Seems like an awesome site you guys got here.

A question: Looking at the rosters and ratings, there are 70+ guys on each roster! i know camp comes with cuts, but are *all of the cuts* going to end up in free agency? i seem to remember the free agency list being huge in '09- but not 500 guys huge! how large was the FA wire last year?

[kehlis]

Quote: Originally Posted by SiNsinNatti

Smh even more. Clearly stated I feel he should be higher rate based on his play last season which is what these ratings are based on. You're taking one word I said and since rephrased, to heart. Rolle out played a lot of the people rated higher than him. Doesn't both me that much just pointing it how it's flawed to me. Rolle's 100 tackles 6 picks = 86 Polamalu's 50 tackles & 2 picks equal 93.

What's Polamalu's rating?

And no, I'm not missing your point. Even your last post mentioned all pro nominations. If you want to talk merit of players go for it, won't intervene because I don't know enough collectively about them to really give a great opinion.

An initial argument was made that he's a perennial pro bowler, that's the only reason I even made a post (and geez I'm sorry I did). No reason to get so defensive about it all.