Madden NFL 15 - Complete Player and Team Ratings for AFC and NFC South

[Darth Aegis]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeah...THAT Guy

Then you see Ryan Fitzpatrick as an 80 and Mike Glennon as a 79... And no, I'm not saying Glennon should be higher than Fitz. I'm saying neither should be remotely that high lol.

They both suck, seems pretty close to me, Glennon should probably be lower though, but I can live with it.

[richiehero]

MLB Akeem Dent doesnt even play for the Falcons anymore. They traded him back in April... Really EA?!

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cutler23

They both suck, seems pretty close to me, Glennon should probably be lower though, but I can live with it.

I just think the gap between the Fitzpatricks and Glennons of the world compared to guys like Luck and Cam needs to be much much bigger.

Glennon has a cannon, but his accuracy numbers should be all be lower, along with stuff like throw on the run.

[friscob]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeah...THAT Guy

I just think the gap between the Fitzpatricks and Glennons of the world compared to guys like Luck and Cam needs to be much much bigger. Glennon has a cannon, but his accuracy numbers should be all be lower, along with stuff like throw on the run.

Throw on the run sure. But if you think his accuracy from the pocket is that much worse (if worse at all) than Cam then you're fooling yourself.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by friscob

Throw on the run sure. But if you think his accuracy from the pocket is that much worse (if worse at all) than Cam then you're fooling yourself.

I can't see Cam and Luck's ratings right now, but I know what Glennons are. They are too high across the board, and Cam and Luck are both around that tier right after the elite QBs, whereas all Glennon has proven to this point is that he's a bottom of the barrel starter with a strong arm. And Fitz has proven himself to be a bottom of the barrel starter as well.

[friscob]

Glennon
68 AWR, 95 thp, 79 short, 77 medium, 86 deep, 87 playaction, 75 on run

Cam
78 AWR, 97 thp, 85 short, 81 medium, 70 deep, 90 play action, 95 on run

Luck
81 AWR, 92 thp, 89 short, 84 medium, 74 deep, 78 play action, 87 run

Seems reasonable enough.

[gr18]

I can't for the .life of me figure out how he got the deep accuracy ratings.Looks like Case Keenum has the best at 90 followed by Matt Cassell at 86,while Brees is 81,Cam,Luck,Ben are in the 70's and Flacco in the 60's to name a few.Bizzaro world???

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Quote: Originally Posted by friscob

Glennon 68 AWR, 95 thp, 79 short, 77 medium, 86 deep, 87 playaction, 75 on run Cam 78 AWR, 97 thp, 85 short, 81 medium, 70 deep, 90 play action, 95 on run Luck 81 AWR, 92 thp, 89 short, 84 medium, 74 deep, 78 play action, 87 run Seems reasonable enough.

I just don't think Glennon should be that close in short and medium, and shouldn't be that ridiculously good on the deep ball either. He's thrown some of the worst deep balls I've ever seen.

And Luck was rated as one of the best play action QBs in the NFL last year while Glennon was poor in that regard, yet Glennon has a huge advantage there.

At the end of the day, I just think there needs to be a much wider range in the ratings.

And the spreadsheet says Fitzpatrick throws a better deep ball than Luck and Cam too, doesn't it? The guys arm is too weak to even throw it down the field.