The Best Madden? A Look Back at Madden NFL 10

[DGMikeBarker]

I wasn't a fan of Madden 10 mostly because of gang tackling. All pro-tak was a gang tackling animation were all the players hugged one another. There were no multiple player violent collisions, like real football.

[gr18]

I liked '10 when it came out because it was the biggest upgrade between years for Madden.Every previous one this Gen was crap IMO.It turned the corner to playable at least.

A couple of years ago there was a thread that was started saying that they liked' 10 better than '12.It was a fairly even sided debate so I decided to pick it up again for around $4 at the time and compare.I was stunned at just how much better '12 looked and played.

"10 didn't have anything going for it except the foot planting that was taken away in '11 with the locomotion which in turn took away the suction that was so prevalent in "10.Zone coverage was bad in '10 and there was the funny looking hitch step when running.When you went to sack the qb he'd throw the flutter ball quite often.The Schwarzenegger-like breaking 8 man gang tackles by running backs and receivers still lacked some sideline awareness.The refs often made the wrong call along sideline catches also.

Anyway '12 wins for me hands down.25 would also get a close second but needs cleaned up a bit still.After that it's a drop off.

[glitch3d]

The draft classes were the best for me. Wish they'd bring those players back.

[Herschie]

Quote: Originally Posted by Devine_Hot_Dog

Madden 2005 is still the greatest of all time.

This. Well, until I get my hands on the PS4 Madden.

[Fist Of Kings]

I didn't like pro tak, I liked the idea but I thought it was executed poorly. A lot of the time there would be a 'pile up', only for the rb to magically blast through the would be tacklers in a straight line straight to the endzone untouched.

[ChangeUp106]

Does anyone have the Madden 25 roster for Madden 10 (PS3)? I'll take any sort of update please!!

[24]

Also had some of the best Draft Classes. Boar Jackson, Mike Zazzalli, Ozzie Jones, Jamarion Bellows I could go on and on.

[Culture Rot]

no aspect of madden 10 is better than any preceding Madden. This is comical