EA's Motion to be Dismissed from O'Bannon Case Denied

[OneDayJD]

Quote: Originally Posted by CLW

...The 9th Circuit has a BAD track record with SCOTUS nearly 80% of their cases are reversed when taken up to the high court. Just sayin'

Heard that. Over here in the 4th Circuit we call the 9th Circuit "moon law" because most of it is bull****.

[OneDayJD]

Quote: Originally Posted by lord_mike

I just read the appellate ruling. If upheld, it pretty much puts the kibosh on any future realistic college games ever. It's amazing that the exact same panel threw out Jim Brown's claims, but are upholding this one. I wonder if they will go to en banc or go straight to the SCOTUS on this one. How the SCOTUS will rule is anyone's guess. They are pretty strong on free speech and are pro business, but it seems that that the players' sob stories are affecting everyone in the legal system. If the SCOTUS denies the appeal in the fall, guess what? EA College football is pretty much done unless the NCAA changes rules on player compensation. If this ruling is upheld, there will be a chilling effect on creativity of all types, from video games, to movies, to books to everything. These judges aren't thinking with their heads on straight.

Where did you find that opinion? Didn't know if it was published yet or if you pulled it off PACER. I'd like to read it as well. Going to check PACER for filings meow... ETA: Nevermind, it's an appellate opinion. I'll find it. I read that wrong. My bad.

[lord_mike]

Quote: Originally Posted by OneDayJD

Heard that. Over here in the 4th Circuit we call the 9th Circuit "moon law" because most of it is bull****.

Unfortunately, it corroborates with a similar 3rd circuit decision from a few months ago that pretty much ruled the same way on an identical case.

[alyssa303]

If you think Thomas`s story is amazing,, last pay-check my sisters mom in law also earned $9055 sitting there a eighteen hour week from there house and their classmate's mother-in-law`s neighbour was doing this for 6 months and got a cheque for over $9055 part-time from a mac. apply the steps available on this page... www.kep2.cℴm

[Linda2]

Avery. you think Irene`s st0ry is unbelievable... last saturday I bought a new Land Rover Range Rover from having made $8217 recently and just a little over 10k this past munth. without a question it is my favourite job Ive ever done. I began this 6 months ago and almost straight away was bringing home at least $85... per-hour. I follow this website,....... www.Yad7.ℂom