NBA 2K13 Top 20 Players and Possible Player Ratings

[jobigdaddy]

Quote: Originally Posted by Biagas

As a thunder fan, im surprised at westbrook over rose. But maybe that had to do something with Rose's injury riddled season vs westbrook's best season. And I'm glad they finally took wade down to a probably 93 where he needs to be Glad russell finally gets some recognition tho and is not 2k's poor man's rose, they both do the same thing except russ can shoot better..I think D rose is a better #1 option and team leader though

lmao did you just say russel westbrook is a better shooter than d rose? you need to watch some basketball bro

[marcfromoregon]

My top 20:
1. LBJ
2. KD
3. CP3
4. D12
5. Kobe
6. DWade
7. DRose
8. Rondo
9. DWill
10. Westbrook
11. Dirk
12. Bynum
13. Melo
14. TP
15. Love
16. Nash
17. Duncan
18. Manu
19. Aldridge
20. Harden

I'm not going to argue over this if you disagree...

[jd_newton72]

Dirk isn't top 15. Specially not after last year. I'm having hard time placing him 16-20.
1 lbj 2 KD 3 d12 4 cp3 5 Kobe 6 drose 7 wade 8 rondo 9 Westbrook 10 Williams 11 love 12 Melo 13 Bynum 14 Parker 15 J smith 16 Duncan 17 gay 18 iggy 19 Griffin 20 Manu 21 nash

[FLAWDAxBALLA954]

Quote: Originally Posted by jd_newton72

Dirk isn't top 15. Specially not after last year. I'm having hard time placing him 16-20. 1 lbj 2 KD 3 d12 4 cp3 5 Kobe 6 drose 7 wade 8 rondo 9 Westbrook 10 Williams 11 love 12 Melo 13 Bynum 14 Parker 15 J smith 16 Duncan 17 gay 18 iggy 19 Griffin 20 Manu 21 nash

Rose better than wade, not yet buddy keep dreaming

[raiderphantom]

Quote: Originally Posted by FLAWDAxBALLA954

Rose better than wade, not yet buddy keep dreaming

Its very debatable. He does have an MVP under his belt and is right there number wise. Wade showed signs of declining last year but hell probably bounce back strong.

[raiderphantom]

Quote: Originally Posted by Belly_of_a_Whale

He's a solid player, but show me how Jefferson has had anywhere close to this impact: 26 ppg, 13.3 rpg, 37% 3pt%, 82% FT% (not to mention, winner of the 3pt contest and the fact that Love's reb, 3pt and FT were even better the year prior)

No disrespect but that's just a basic stat line with little detail or insight. I understand all the Love fans but when it comes to winning you need guys who can create their own shot and do it EFFECIENTLY. Jefferson has a far better post game and the team revolves around him. Love is a spot up shooter who is a scrapper that scores off assisted baskets and cleaning up his own misses. That's not enough to win. I know I'm in the vast minority here and I don't expect to change anyone's minds but at least try to see where I'm coming from philisophically.

[master4183]

2k is all screwed up when it comes to Rose! He destroyed Chris Paul and he's faster than Westbrook...has a better IQ and Westbrook has Durant! Rose is the only elite player who doesn't have another elite player on his team yet he still puts up numbers just as good if not better than most rated higher than himself! He also was the only athlete who consistently kept getting no fouls called as he drove lanes...yet his percentages are still up there with and better than the others... Westbrook has Durant, Wade has LBJ, Kobe had Bynum, and CP3 has Griffin. The man gets injured one season and they forget how unstoppable he is:/ That's just disrespectful to have Westbrook over him and CP3 two points higher. At first I thought it was because of his injury...but if that were the case wtf is Howard doing at a 95! Rose should be a 94-95. Or at least just as good as the other elite smalls in the league...Westbrook doesn't belong there...91 at best! He'd get destroyed if the defense only had to focus on him.

[FedExPope]

Quote: Originally Posted by SouthBeach

You know why I disagree? Cause Wade creates his own shot on a more consistent basis than LeBron. LeBron isn't a score-first player like Wade. To your point, Wade does get some production from LeBron - not all of it. And given Wade being injured for the most part of the season and still pulling 30pt games out when necessary, he's becoming more efficient with LeBron on the court. Not sure if you watch every Heat game, but down here, I've seen Wade play like this all throughout 2009 and the only thing that has changed is his speed.

But I think its true that hes the least important of the 3. We saw the chaos that ensued with bron and d-wade without bosh, and i think its safe to assume that a d-wade + bosh combo isn't going to get a ring by itself. But I don't think hes a B-level star...i guess in the vein of what Nash is now. But hes getting close to that dreaded age for shooting guards, and hes not a particularly good jumpshooter, something I think will help a joe johnson or has helped kobe remain productive at advanced age.