Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Top 10 Receivers/Tight Ends

[ABR173rd]

Quote: Originally Posted by Chrisksaint

Eh it's debatable to say Nicks better then Colston when you at it over a career, last season yes but not by the wide margin you say. Dwayne Bowe is right there as well

If the ratings are based on body of work or even last regular season its highly debatable. Maybe a little bit of homerism on my part as well, but it seems like Colston gets slighted every season, he's not a burner but the guy is not scared to go over the middle and has made some impressive catches over the course of last season.

[MaddenSaints]

Quote: Originally Posted by CowherPower

No Mike Wallace??

He is not a top 10 receiver.

[gator3guy]

Nicks was arguably a top 3 receiver in 2010. Only thing holding this guy back is injuries. He's a beast.

[RateSports]

Quote: Originally Posted by bmj2k7

In that one comment you lost ALL credibility. AJ was a rookie, he has to do it atleast 2 more years, Bowe maybe bc his size id still take Knicks and im a PATS FAN, Jones another rookie, with Ryan at QB he will never get close in the next 2 years to Knicks and definately not White, Colston is a JOKE right? he basically a young Burress with Brees, Jackson is the only one you get any credit for but hes on a terrible team with a average QB, Jackson is a NO, refuses to get near anyone, Wallace is fast but in the same boat as Jackson but is a little more bulky, Garcon, must be a redskins fanboy or your just have no football IQ

You lost all credibility when you referred to Hakeem Nicks as Knicks.

[TOmuch81]

Jason Witten isn't on this list. Anyone else have a problem with that?

[MaddenSaints]

Quote: Originally Posted by TOmuch81

Jason Witten isn't on this list. Anyone else have a problem with that?

Personally, no.

[TOmuch81]

Quote: Originally Posted by MaddenSaints

Personally, no.

I guess consistency doesn't hold weight with you. Top all around TE for the last 3 yrs.

[ABR173rd]

Quote: Originally Posted by TOmuch81

I guess consistency doesn't hold weight with you. Top all around TE for the last 3 yrs.

I don't think Vernon Davis deserves to be on the list, however if the ratings were based on body of work throughout their careers then I would have no problem with Witten taking V.D.'s spot on the list.