Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

[adub88]

Is Luck the highest ever rated rookie QB in Madden? I would have to think that is the case.

[BigshotSportcenter]

So Andrew Luck rated better then Andy Dalton already SMH!!!!!!!

[Pappy Knuckles]

AWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW YEAH! I'm about to get busy with Luck in our online franchise. After that catch he had last season at Stanford they even gave him some nice receiving ratings. Colts!

Andrew Luck
Overall 84
Speed 82
Acceleration 88
Catching 72
Throw Power 92
Throw Accuracy 88
Jumping 86
Spectacular Catch 83
Throw Accuracy Short 93
Throw Accuracy Mid 90
Throw Accuracy Deep 81
Play Action 74
Throw on Run 88

[jmurphy31]

Rookie QBs shouldn't be rated in the mid 80s until they prove it on the field. With roster updates available every week during the season, it shouldn't be a big deal.

Brady probably has to have a stronger THP to keep his OVR high.

[Big FN Deal]

It's understandable that people are in a tizzy about the ratings BUT IF AWR and DPP were tuned well, this stuff would be secondary, as it should be. Physical talent and skill sets are at a premium in the NFL but it's the mental focus and consistency that sets players apart.

I am not suggesting that AWR and DPP are tuned well in M13 because I don't know, just saying if they were, it would be the proper equalizer to the ratings. So those bothered by Luck or whatever Rookie coming in with higher physical and/or skill ratings than existing players, it's the AWR and DPP of those existing players in comparison to those Rookies that should allow them to still perform better on the field until those Rookies have proven themselves.

[TheBleedingRed21]

The problem with waiting until the roookies "prove" they deserve that is that people who play with those teams that are expecting them to be good, with no edits, we would have to wait until donny releases the new update through the mid-end of the season which by then I would already be deep into my franchise.

But that is my opinion on why it is done that way.

[Chrisksaint]

Never been one to care too much on ratings, but Brees with a deep ball accuracy of 84 compared to RG3 who is higher is ridiculous when stats show Brees has been one of the best at it over the last few years

[LBzrule]

Quote: Originally Posted by Dj_MyTime

I just had to double check after reading this...it's 86.

Ooops saw the wrong line. Ok my bad. But still I'm mad and there will be no rest until Flacco's throwing power is raised.