Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[raiders81tim]

Quote: Originally Posted by cusefan74

Except that they both have won Super Bowls, and Rivers has not won anything.

Superbowl is a individual stat since when? Funny stat in every single playoff game Rivers has lost his team has given up 32 or more points. He's only one man.

[DPZ1156]

Being a giants fan I feel that Eli should be 95. He put up great numbers last year and won the super bowl but isn't a top 3. My ratings would be:

Drew Brees: 99 (Broke basically every record)

Aaron Rodgers: 98 (Great QB but Brees is just better)

Tom Brady: 97 (Still one of the best there is and is constantly great)

Eli Manning: 95 (Proved he was one of the elite QBs in football but isn't yet on the level as the above 3)

Peyton Manning: 93 (Missed a year and is older but still looks to be good)

Matt Stafford: 93 (Put up great numbers but isn't a great QB yet)

Ben Rothlesinberger: 92 (Good QB on a great team)

Philip Rivers: 91 (Good QB but a great QB would have won with that team.
The bad team excuse is pointless if you want to consider him one of the top 5 in the league because he would have led the team to the SB if he was)

Tony Romo: 89 (A good QB sometimes, an above average QB other times)

Mike Vick: 88 (He is fast but not the great thrower he used to be)

[Instant C1a55ic]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiders81tim

Eli vastly overrated same for Ben. No way either of these two are better than Phillip Rivers.

I would say they are, both got rings.

the only overrated one is Peyton Manning, with that year out i would have said he should have been started out at 89-90. then raise/drop if he performs/under-performs.

[lalykind]

Quote: Originally Posted by 43M

Stafford should not be a 95 based on one season where all he did most of the year was throw the ball up to an uncoverable WR. Staffod led the league in bad decision percentage and was one had alot of bad throws to Megatron that he got bailed out on. Put him at 90 and I can agree with those ratings.

pause! so what dud brees do with uncoverable jimmy? thats just the type of reciever calvin is .... JUST THROW..AND THOU SHALT RECIEVE!!!

[lalykind]

Quote: Originally Posted by goravens2052

Well I don't blame you for saying this, I mean the Eagles don't have a Clutch QB so you wouldn't know what it is like to have a Clutch QB. Also from your statement, I didn't realize stats brought home a Super Bowl, last I checked a win-loss record did, and having a clutch QB in the 4th quarter to help you win is a bad thing according to you? QB Rating? All that matters to me is a Win-Loss Record. I could care less if Joe Flacco throws for 5,000 yards if the Ravens didn't win enough games to make the playoffs that same year, then who cares. Oh and your only as good as your last game, and Romo failed in Week 17 in a WIN OR GO HOME situation. Eli, Tebow and Flacco are all better clutch quarterbacks as at least they are able to complete a 4th comeback.

PAUSE! last time i checked giants record wasnt really something to be bragging about! yall only had one more win then the pigeons and yall still wasnt over ten wins so lets get something straight the giants are a show of CRUZE and CO. Eli is just a name attached to payton so it makes everybody throw a parade when he does something even my quarterback could do(carson Palmer) throw the ball on a team with no D to win a sb....o whoopdy doo...you cant see now but im giving you two thumbs up for that....

[lalykind]

Quote: Originally Posted by cusefan74

Except that they both have won Super Bowls, and Rivers has not won anything.

SO i guess dan marino would be overated if he was a 95

[lalykind]

and on the subject of mathew he threw for over five.....five thousand.....five thoussanndd yaaarrds!!!!!! what is not elite about that?.......o my bad i forgot he had a handicap advantage with calvin and all since no one can stick him my bad they dont count i guess....,,,

[Dwaresacksqb]

I'm just happy Romo has finally earned the community's respect. All his haters just make themselves look so stupid nowadays.

As far as the ratings go, I could easily complain and make EA look silly but I stopped letting them play on my emotions. I just try to enjoy whatever garbage they want to give me because of the NFL Logo stamped on the cover.