Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[DukeC]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

So, Cutler has never had any of those days in his 6 yr career and hasn't thrown any bad passes?

Good God don't bring up the Denver days. Dude would be so putrid it was sickening.

Other days he'd look like Elway.

More often than not he simply looked above average, mainly because of his INT problem.

[raiders81tim]

Quote: Originally Posted by FedExPope

This is just so flabbergasting a comment I don't know what to say. Especially when you use the word 'vastly'.

Eli is not an elite QB. He just isn't. He is one of the most inconstant starting QBs in the NFL right now. He's had 2 above average seasons in 8 years starting. While Rivers has had 3 elite seasons in 6 years starting. In terms of on the field skill level it really isn't close.

Your talking about giving a 97 rating to a QB that over his career doesn't even complete 60% of his passes. To me thats insane.

[DaBear23]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

So, Cutler has never had any of those days in his 6 yr career and hasn't thrown any bad passes?

lol mathew stafford has never had a good game against the bears. look at tillman in the video giving magethron the business. according to madden rating tillman does not have a chance against megathron. jenning was one of the few db that did not allow a td all season, but according to madden jenning suck. madden rating is bs, and jay cutler is wey better than stafford.

[DeuceDouglas]

This thread is the absolute definition of why fans should never be allowed to vote on anything to do with ratings.

[Big FN Deal]

Quote: Originally Posted by roadman

So, Cutler has never had any of those days in his 6 yr career and hasn't thrown any bad passes?

Not to make this thread all about Jay Cutler but is it just me or does Cutler remind anyone else of Jeff George? lol. All that touted talent, arm strength and bravado, without any consistency. I am not downing the guy, just thought it was weird I have never noticed anybody make a correlation between the two, maybe I am just an old fuddy duddy and nobody alse even remembers Jeff George.

[raiders81tim]

Quote: Originally Posted by Big FN Deal

Not to make this thread all about Jay Cutler but is it just me or does Cutler remind anyone else of Jeff George? lol. All that touted talent, arm strength and bravado, without any consistency. I am not downing the guy, just thought it was weird I have never noticed anybody make a correlation between the two, maybe I am just an old fuddy duddy and nobody alse even remembers Jeff George.

I do, Culter is far better the Jeff. Blitz Jeff and he would go into a shell. At least Culter is willing to play hard no matter what.

[DaBear23]

Quote: Originally Posted by Big FN Deal

Not to make this thread all about Jay Cutler but is it just me or does Cutler remind anyone else of Jeff George? lol. All that touted talent, arm strength and bravado, without any consistency. I am not downing the guy, just thought it was weird I have never noticed anybody make a correlation between the two, maybe I am just an old fuddy duddy and nobody alse even remembers Jeff George.

comparing cutler to jeff george is not cool. the bears was playoff bond before jay cutler got injured. the bears had a 7 and 3 record before he gat injured. the season before that, he too the bears to the nfc championship game and the bears lost to the superbowl champion (parkers). jeff george and cutler should not be mention in the same sentence.

[gakthatswhatsup]

Where's Tim Tebow? He's easily the greatest quarterback in the history of Football. Probly the greatest player. He's coming into camp at like 400 pounds and he'll probly win the rushing title and have the highest passer rating this year. He'll be MVP like 10 years in a row now that he's playing in a city that will embrace his greatness....Just think of what happened when babe ruth came to NY. Anyway i think most of those guys are actually pretty bad quarterbacks and Tim Tebow should be a 99 and no one else should be above 40. JUST BEING REAL.