Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[StrawHat Patriot]

Quote: Originally Posted by bspang2

Tony Romo is a 90 Overall???? BASED ON WHAT? Tony Romo has not proven himself as a winner or a clutch QB for years and has only reached the playoffs twice and has never made it past the first round of the playoffs.

Tony Romo is a 90 overall based on his stats because he passed for more touchdowns than Eli Manning, threw less picks than Drew Brees, Eli Manning, and Tom Brady, his completion percentage is higher than Tom Brady and Eli Manning, He is in the top 5 all-time for career passer rating, and was one of the league leaders in 4th Quarter Passer Rating.

Romo is better than Eli, the only reason why Tony's teams don't make it that far is because they never unite like Eli's Giants teams do. The cowboys as a TEAM seem to never rise up and play their best when they need to. Look at Week 17 against the Giants, that game was close at one point, but the Cowboys defense couldn't step up. Tony is also unlucky as even Giants fans mention that Eli can at times throw off his back foot and won't get picked off because his receivers will actually make a play.

Tony Romo freaking lost a game that he led would should have been the game winning drive if not for his own coach icing his OWN kicker.

[goravens2052]

Quote: Originally Posted by mojo6911

Based on? Cutler's HIGHEST QB rating is 3 points lower than Romo's LOWEST QB rating. Romo is better in just about every category.

Way to shorten my post as I explained why. The Bears were on their way to the playoffs and were close to locking up a playoff spot before Jay Cutler got injured. If Cutler didn't get injured, they would have been in the playoffs no doubt. Romo better than Cutler? Come talk to me when Romo becomes a clutch player and doesn't fail under pressure.

[Champion8877]

Just for the heck of it, this is how I think the ratings should look. Not that my opinion really matters though.

Aaron Rodgers-99
Drew Brees-98
Tom Brady-97
Tony Romo-94
Peyton Manning-93
Big Ben-93
Eli Manning-92
Phillip Rivers-92
Matthew Stafford-90
Michael Vick-89

[coogrfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by bspang2

Tony Romo is a 90 Overall???? BASED ON WHAT?

4th highest qb rating in the league last season do anything for you?

Quote: Originally Posted by bspang2

Tony Romo has not proven himself as a winner or a clutch QB for years

False. For his career Romo has 13 4th qtr comebacks and 14 game winning drives.

http://www.pro-football-reference.co...layer=RomoTo00

Quote: Originally Posted by bspang2

and has only reached the playoffs twice

False. The Cowboys have made the postseason 3 times in the 5 seasons in which Romo started more than half their games (Romo missed the final 10 games in 2010 due to injury).

Quote: Originally Posted by bspang2

and has never made it past the first round of the playoffs.

False. The Boys defeated Philly in the Wild Card round in 2009 only to lose in the divisional round to Minn.

Anything else?

[StrawHat Patriot]

Quote: Originally Posted by Champion8877

Just for the heck of it, this is how I think the ratings should look. Not that my opinion really matters though. Aaron Rodgers-99 Drew Brees-98 Tom Brady-97 Tony Romo-94 Peyton Manning-93 Big Ben-93 Eli Manning-92 Phillip Rivers-92 Matthew Stafford-90 Michael Vick-89

Those are good but they should be scaled down

[ShaneTheMaster]

EA might as well use a 20 point rating scale, since they dont use 0-80. Of course, then 0-15 wouldn't be used

[codyj123_321]

Quote: Originally Posted by EaglesFan1825

Clutch isn't everything. I guess Tebow should be 97 also...

Bet anything that Tebow's throw accuracy will be like an 84 or something when really it should be about a 70 and that's being generous. I won't be able to edit it either which really sucks. I don't wanna see him putting up 3000+ yards in my CC cause that just isn't realistic.

[riggs6taters]

Quote: Originally Posted by ShaneTheMaster

EA might as well use a 20 point rating scale, since they dont use 0-80. Of course, then 0-15 wouldn't be used