Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[Jimi XIII]

Stafford at 91? Most of his stats are dependent on the cover man, Calvin Johnson. Ugh reason, #231 why overalls need a complete overhaul or removed.

Then Rivers & Vick coming off bad season should be no more than 86-88 going by typical Madden standards...80-84 if going by stricter more spread out ratings like it should be to differentiate the good from the great. Then of course they can update the roster depending on how they play throughout the year.


It's time to adopt the Abilities System, a combination of that and ratings or just something different. Eli is not a 97 QB but he's Clutch, Durable and has a special kind of Leadership ability while being a bit INT prone at times though.

[kd25]

There needs to be a big gap between the top 3 QBs and the rest

no way in hell should Roethlisberger be 95 if Brees is 98. it's just stupid. dude averages 20 TD per year and had just 21 last season

Brees has two 5,000 yard seasons
Roethlisberger has two 4,000 yard seasons

they shouldn't be close at all.

[kd25]

1. Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers 99 overall
2. Drew Brees, New Orleans Saints 98 overall
3. Tom Brady, New England Patriots 98 overall
5. Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos: 91 overall
4. Eli Manning, New York Giants 91 overall
6. Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers: 90 overall
7. Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions: 90 overall
8. Tony Romo, Dallas Cowboys: 90 overall
9. Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagles: 89 overall
10. Cam Newton, Carolina Panthers: 89 overall

[1D4ever]

Quote: Originally Posted by kd25

1. Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers 99 overall 2. Drew Brees, New Orleans Saints 98 overall 3. Tom Brady, New England Patriots 98 overall 5. Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos: 91 overall 4. Eli Manning, New York Giants 91 overall 6. Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers: 90 overall 7. Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions: 90 overall 8. Tony Romo, Dallas Cowboys: 90 overall 9. Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagles: 89 overall 10. Cam Newton, Carolina Panthers: 89 overall

I would still lower the top 3 by 3 points myself, but those are so much better.

Mine would be
1. Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers 96 overall
2. Drew Brees, New Orleans Saints 95 overall
3. Tom Brady, New England Patriots 95 overall
4. Eli Manning, New York Giants 91 overall
5. Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos: 91 overall
6. Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers: 90 overall
7. Tony Romo, Dallas Cowboys: 90 overall
8. Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions: 89 overall
9. Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagles: 89 overall
10. Cam Newton, Carolina Panthers: 89 overall

[CujoMatty]

Even if Chewbacca was doing Peyton's neck surgery and accidently put his head on backwards I'd take him over Eli every day of the week.

[stlpimpmonsta]

Fun fact: Alex Smith has a 5 - 2 record against those QBs. Where is his 99?!

[jrivera34]

Quote: Originally Posted by cujomatty

Even if Chewbacca was doing Peyton's neck surgery and accidently put his head on backwards I'd take him over Eli every day of the week.

I still think Eli is more clutch then his brother and if I had one drive to win the game I would go with Eli.

The Aaron Rodgers video made me laugh as they showed him carving up the Giants. They should have showed Tuck and Osi sacking his arse lol.

GMEN for a repeat in 2012/2013!

As for the ratings, why do people suggest dropping someone 1-2 points? It makes absolutely no difference. I think the top 5 QBs should be in the 90s, 5-10 in the 80s and go from there.

This is where I liked All Pro Football better. I know there were numbers behind the abilities but these debates are really meaningless when playing the game.

[Gaycandybacon]

Alex Smith by himself?