Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[moylan1234]

Quote: Originally Posted by slappybrown

This is simply wrong with respect to Ben; Rivers had a lower passer rating last year, check your numbers chief Oh are you the guy who uses the espn version when it suits? Your posts here make more sense now

wrong on Eli too here's the top 11 qbr from NFL.com


1 Aaron Rodgers 122.5
2 Drew Brees 110.6
3 Tom Brady 105.6
4 Tony Romo 102.5
5 M. Stafford 97.2
6 Matt Schaub 96.8
7 Eli Manning 92.9
8 Matt Ryan 92.2
9 Alex Smith 90.7
10 B.Roethlisberger 90.1
11 Philip Rivers SD 88.7

[SteelerSpartan]

This thread is a Perfect example of why ratings are too subjective to be locked down and forced onto people.....NFL fans could debate this stuff for an eternity

Now people will be even more at the mercy of some frivolous popularity contest designed only to generate marketing buzz....

I absolutely hate how they treat this area of their game

Donny "I Love to Give Everybody a 90+" Moore and his ratings system needs a wake up call

[Av2002]

Quote: Originally Posted by LastExit

Yeah, it didn't look too good but that could have been an early build (although I don't know why they would advertise this late with a beta build or whatever). The demo will be out soon enough and will tell the tale.

This build wasn't a late build. They say the art team usually the last people to tweak the game. And as u see the nice cleats u can clearly see its at that stage. The shoes look good but they aren't multi color like jean Adams said they would be. And every players has the same color patterns that's not right with the real nfl

[TheBleedingRed21]

I do not understand why some of you guys bash Eli. Giants have become a pass heavy team. He might not be "pretty" to watch sometimes, but the dude is a winner, he gets the job done.

[Rondo is GOD]

As long as they play like themselves I don't care if everyone is rated at 99.

[raiders81tim]

Quote: Originally Posted by SNashty3

Eli and Ben both have 2 Super Bowls, Rivers has never played in one...

Since when is a Superbowl win an individual stat?

[raiders81tim]

Quote: Originally Posted by slappybrown

This is simply wrong with respect to Ben; Rivers had a lower passer rating last year, check your numbers chief Oh are you the guy who uses the espn version when it suits? Your posts here make more sense now

I only use total qbr, it's a better overall rating for the position. Just look at how the two are calculated. QB rating puts far too much weight into pass completions %, and doesn't take into account drops, sacks or pass interference plays. Total qbr is simply the best way to evaluate a QB.

[Jdoug312]

Quote: Originally Posted by SteelerSpartan

This thread is a Perfect example of why ratings are too subjective to be locked down and forced onto people.....NFL fans could debate this stuff for an eternity Now people will be even more at the mercy of some frivolous popularity contest designed only to generate marketing buzz.... I absolutely hate how they treat this area of their game Donny "I Love to Give Everybody a 90+" Moore and his ratings system needs a wake up call

Quoted for emphasis. I'm sorry but in that meeting where the team decided that it was okay to remove the ability to edit ratings, they should have released a poll listing why the change would be needed, and ask the consumers whether or not they'd be willing to suffer through that, or wait another year for CCM.