Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[N51_rob]

Quote: Originally Posted by EaglesFan1825

40 time wise, Vick is. He doesn't look like he's lost any speed either. The fans will ruin some ratings.

I'm a skins fans so take this with a grain of salt, but RGIII ran a 4.35 and was on the Baylor track team. I think he is faster than Vick today. Maybe not when Vick first came out, but today I think RGIII is faster.

That said, these fan vote polls on ratings undermine the entire madden ratings. What research goes into these if "fans" can dictate some ratings. It's especially crazy to let them pick a rating like speed which is the end all be all in this generations madden.

[SNashty3]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiders81tim

Eli vastly overrated same for Ben. No way either of these two are better than Phillip Rivers.

Eli and Ben both have 2 Super Bowls, Rivers has never played in one...

[MaddenSaints]

Brees it better than Rodgers, he should be a 99 not Aaron. He broke one of the hardest records. Weather the Packer were 15-1 it does not matter, Brees should be first.

[slappybrown]

Quote: Originally Posted by A_New_Classic

So Super Bowl winning Eli should be dropped 2 points to 95 after having a monster year, but Big Ben is fine right there? lol Steeler fans

By any metric, whether team accomplishments or individual production, Ben has outplayed Eli. Sorry that's just reality.

Oh, I mean "lol Giants fans"

[N51_rob]

Let's go ahead and cut out the "lol ______ fans" comments. They are not needed to discuss these ratings. Thanks.

[slappybrown]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiders81tim

Please dude had a higher qbr than both Eli and Ben in his worst season ever as a starter. Rivers is a stud, very underrated.

This is simply wrong with respect to Ben; Rivers had a lower passer rating last year, check your numbers chief

Oh are you the guy who uses the espn version when it suits? Your posts here make more sense now

[Sublime12089]

If I was doing it:


1. Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers 98 overall
2. Drew Brees, New Orleans Saints 97 overall
3. Tom Brady, New England Patriots 97 overall
4. Eli Manning, New York Giants 94 overall
5. Peyton Manning, Denver Broncos: 93 overall
6. Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers: 93 overall
7. Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers: 90 overall
8. Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions: 90 overall
9. Tony Romo, Dallas Cowboys: 88 overall
10. Michael Vick, Philadelphia Eagles: 87 overall

[jmurphy31]

My thoughts:

1. Releasing these now are only for marketing and to generate a buzz.

2. Why not release all the ratings not just overall. Also, why just the top 10. I'm actually more intrigued with what the lower tier QBs will be rated .

3. My wishes for stretched out ratings looks to be just a wish

4. I thought they said players will start lower than there actual OVR during franchise mode (Brady was a 90 in the one video). So why not talk about this some where on how it will work

5. The video didnt make thed game look good.