Operation Sports Full Minors 2012 Roster - Opening Day Edition Available Now

[sfgiants28]

Downloaded the rosters earlier today. Thanks for all the work you guys put into them.

[RidinDwnKingsley]

Quote: Originally Posted by seanjeezy

Then why not replace Matt Hobgood? Hasn't made it out of A Ball and is out for the year, perfect candidate for replacement. I don't see how the "break the game" argument is even valid, since you aren't adding top prospects, your replacing them with AAA scrubs. Only Rymer Liriano had an A potential and deservedly so, he's a top 100 prospect. Donavan Tate would have been a better choice: Lower level, lower ceiling, older, etc. I'm not trying to start a fight or anything like that, so I'll leave it at that, but to say you don't like the pitch edits when one of the main complaints about the game is the lack of realistic repertoires is a head scratcher lol, especially since the Andy Pettitte and Jamie Moyer you used have my pitch edits

Its all a matter of opinion....

Pitch edits across the board arent my thing...but hey since you know everything I will leave the roster updates from now on in your hands "Oh great one"..since obviously you are the roster "guru"....I love this place and most of the people here but the thing that annoys me the most is the lack of appreciation some have for the countless hours and hours of work that some people do on these sets...some people just wanna rip others work...if you want I can do a suggestive review of the pitch edits roster but you wouldnt like it im sure..so I wont...you can now carry on with how great you feel the game is because your sliders " slide" 1/4 more across the TV screens in America than the ones in the update I put out.....carry on.

[Metsfan31]

Anyone have a link? My network is down.

[Hootiefish]

Guys stop fighting. You're scaring me.

[crques]

Quote: Originally Posted by RidinDwnKingsley

Its all a matter of opinion.... Pitch edits across the board arent my thing...but hey since you know everything I will leave the roster updates from now on in your hands "Oh great one"..since obviously you are the roster "guru"....I love this place and most of the people here but the thing that annoys me the most is the lack of appreciation some have for the countless hours and hours of work that some people do on these sets...some people just wanna rip others work...if you want I can do a suggestive review of the pitch edits roster but you wouldnt like it im sure..so I wont...you can now carry on with how great you feel the game is because your sliders " slide" 1/4 more across the TV screens in America than the ones in the update I put out.....carry on.

Ridin, just wanted to let you know that I appreciate your rosters and I'm not a fan of pitch edits across the board either. Therefore, the next time you want to do an update and upload it to the vault, think of it as being for those that appreciate your work. It is easy to pick at the minor league rosters whenever you are a fan of a specific team and see a player or two in question for that organization. However, thinking of these edits as a whole and realizing just how much work goes into this for every team, not just one, you should gain a whole new appreciation for the work that has been put into them.

[seanjeezy]

Quote: Originally Posted by RidinDwnKingsley

Its all a matter of opinion.... Pitch edits across the board arent my thing...but hey since you know everything I will leave the roster updates from now on in your hands "Oh great one"..since obviously you are the roster "guru"....I love this place and most of the people here but the thing that annoys me the most is the lack of appreciation some have for the countless hours and hours of work that some people do on these sets...some people just wanna rip others work...if you want I can do a suggestive review of the pitch edits roster but you wouldnt like it im sure..so I wont...you can now carry on with how great you feel the game is because your sliders " slide" 1/4 more across the TV screens in America than the ones in the update I put out.....carry on.

Seriously? Where am I "ripping" you? Just because I don't use those stupid smiley face things you think I'm slamming your work? I even offered possible replacement candidates that are a better fit, but I guess that isn't good enough.

Please, review the pitch edits set, I encourage it. How am I supposed to make it better if I don't know what needs to be fixed? There is a reason why we post our stuff here, community feedback is a big deal to me.

Really though, do you think I pulled all of the pitch data out of my a** or something? Or maybe you think pitch f/x isn't a valid system, I don't know, but how can you dispute something that is backed by statistical data? If the data exists, why not utilize it? Pitch f/x says the average fastball/changeup separation is around 6 MPH and the average slider breaks around 4.5 inches. Do you know what it was in OSFM? 10.46 MPH and 8 inches, not realistic in the slightest. Do you know how many players these global edits affected? 262/1210, all minor leaguers. The other 948 players had pitch f/x data available, no subjectivity involved, just hard facts. But by all means share your opinion, I would love to hear it since I am open to taking suggestions.

[RidinDwnKingsley]

Quote: Originally Posted by seanjeezy

Seriously? Where am I "ripping" you? Just because I don't use those stupid smiley face things you think I'm slamming your work? I even offered possible replacement candidates that are a better fit, but I guess that isn't good enough. Please, review the pitch edits set, I encourage it. How am I supposed to make it better if I don't know what needs to be fixed? There is a reason why we post our stuff here, community feedback is a big deal to me. Really though, do you think I pulled all of the pitch data out of my a** or something? Or maybe you think pitch f/x isn't a valid system, I don't know, but how can you dispute something that is backed by statistical data? If the data exists, why not utilize it? Pitch f/x says the average fastball/changeup separation is around 6 MPH and the average slider breaks around 4.5 inches. Do you know what it was in OSFM? 10.46 MPH and 8 inches, not realistic in the slightest. Do you know how many players these global edits affected? 262/1210, all minor leaguers. The other 948 players had pitch f/x data available, no subjectivity involved, just hard facts. But by all means share your opinion, I would love to hear it since I am open to taking suggestions.

Dude since we were putting the original OSFM set together this year you have had complaints and criticisms of work done by many, as you said it "bothers" you Well your criticisms of others work on a consistent basis "bothers" me....if you dont like the work or the sets please dont use them....Im done now...thats my pitch fx statistical data for the night...Im out.

[Side Effect]

I like your 1.5 rosters Ridin. I'm not really interested in the pitch edits either. I'm working off your May 9 update roster and applying V2 cosmetics edits and making an optimal, no injuries or DL roster.