Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

[aholbert32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeats

Good grief man, it's called an opinion... just like you have an opinion that more people care about editing. I disagree with you. A few dozen posters on OS care obviously and may not buy the game. But past that, Madden sales will be in the millions as usual. It's not going to affect EA in any way, which is why they can risk removing editing. And they know that.

Thats silly reasoning. There are alot of features within Madden that you can remove that wouldnt effect the sales. That doesnt mean that the features should be removed. I believe that you could remove online franchise and the numbers would be relatively the same. Why? Because its the only NFL game and some need their NFL fix.

[CRMosier_LM]

Quote: Originally Posted by drlw322

I just wonder if they unlock just equipment, names, and numbers, would it still cause a major bug. I hope the main issue is the rating edit and they can unlock the other things.

i would say the main issue would be ratings and positions. hopefully they find a way to unlock the the other stuff.

[Yeats]

Quote: Originally Posted by moylan

but my opinion is backed up with actual facts that's the difference

Yeah, you insist there are more people who are interested. Them's some facts there. No, that's called your opinion I'm afraid.

[aholbert32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeats

Well like I said, a larger percentage of Madden gamers will care about the removal of armband and number editing, of course. But as far as editing player ratings, no.

I dont get your point. You cant edit ANYTHING in CCM. Thats the issue. Not that the editing is limited.

[jpollard25]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeats

Good grief man, it's called an opinion... just like you have an opinion that more people care about editing. I disagree with you. A few dozen posters on OS care obviously and may not buy the game. But past that, Madden sales will be in the millions as usual. It's not going to affect EA in any way, which is why they can risk removing editing. And they know that.

Geez...it's a few dozen in a cross-section of a few dozen..."opinion" and statistics are not friends...state your opinion...stop using numbers.

[moylan1234]

Quote: Originally Posted by CRMosier_LM

The exact thing you just said without the fluff... no way they could get it in the game and have it tuned in time for release.

exactly that's what I've been saying all along. they knew they wouldn't have time to flush it out completely so they went ahead without it. and for the record i've stated on the NCAA boards that I totally understand and respect their decision and I wish Madden would've taken that same approach to CC

I love fluff especially with peanut butter, but I don't get what I ever said that was inaccurate

[Yeats]

Quote: Originally Posted by aholbert32

Thats silly reasoning. There are alot of features within Madden that you can remove that wouldnt effect the sales. That doesnt mean that the features should be removed. I believe that you could remove online franchise and the numbers would be relatively the same. Why? Because its the only NFL game and some need their NFL fix.

I'm not supporting the decision to remove editing, I think it's terrible they did that. But it doesn't surprise me, EA does this sort of thing all the time with their games. I'm just a realist. They obviously felt they could get away with it and that it wouldn't hurt their bottomline. And why? Because they know very few people care and/or will buy the game anyway.

[moylan1234]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yeats

Yeah, you insist there are more people who are interested. Them's some facts there. No, that's called your opinion I'm afraid.

I never insisted anything actually. I provided a fact that every sports game released today has this a fact you still haven't addressed at all