NBA 2K12 Player Ratings Revealed, Including All Free Agents

[JerzeyReign]

Personally, I think all of the ratings are pretty fair. Some of you guys are looking at small stretches (example, Gasol Vs. the Spurs in the playoffs) as your guidelines.

I know they work hard at their craft but forum roster editors only get tendencies right. Most of their edits are personal opinions or are dictated by complaints on the forum.

[Melo7NYKtru]

Quote: Originally Posted by SouthBeach

Derrick Rose 92 - Taken from Defense Insight If you wanted to add his name/rating to the original post.

holy crap. Thats ****. Rose IS NOT better than Melo. WTF is wrong with the 2k insider? dam man He pissed me off last year and he did it again.

[Kbjunior]

At PF I think Kevin Love should be at least a 83 with Zach Randolph he averaged more Rebounds Dirk should be at least a 89..I See KG should be a 80 along wit Bosh at PF but maybe he's higher cause he's a better defender..and Grant hill bump him down a bit 75 everything else is good

[kenny123123]

kobe 94 smh

[dukedude24]

terrible ratings....

a lot overrates and underrates......

[ckmtexas]

Honestly I'd love 2k to get rid of overall rankings. All they do is make people mad that so and so is overrated or underrated when there are usually(not always) good reasons for it. Some players have strengths that are not prototypical for their position such as Dirk. He is a great shooter but that doesn't make him look great as a powerforward because PF's are about post defense rebounding and post offense. Dirk's good at one of those 3 things and in a completely different league than any other PF in something that they are not supposed to be good at. So Dirk as an 85 will be able to make jumpshots against anyone but has alot of trouble guarding Randolph in the post. Sounds fair to be. Also the reason Lebron is always rated so high is because he doesn't have any measurable weakness for a Small forward. His game ranks highly in almost every statistical measurement of course he will be rated higher then others every year.

[Ken North]

Quote: Originally Posted by Noof

I don't understand why practically everyone seems to have gotten worse, but they boosted Lebron up to 98. The guy has in A- in Out.

Must be because of how dominant he was in the Finals... Wait no, that was the guy they gave an 85...

2K shares ESPN's bromance for Lebron, this isn't news.

[Dachozen1]

77 is just right for Boozer...and as for Deng, I think he should be rated atleast 80.. He was a big key to why the Bulls had the most wins in the NBA. Deng has great stamina and defense...That Bulls team doesn't look like a 62 win team right there...disappointing