Madden NFL 12 Review (360/PS3)

[jackw]

It's crazy, when the game really sucks, OS gives it a 9.0, when it's actually pretty good, you give it a 7.5? Make up your mind bro.

[Ducereus]

Does anyone know why I can't heal any of my legendary cards in Madden 12???

[jamie1981]

Okay so this is the first time in about 10 years that I didn't buy this game on the release date. I am so confused on whether to buy this or not.

[PVarck31]

Quote: Originally Posted by jackw

It's crazy, when the game really sucks, OS gives it a 9.0, when it's actually pretty good, you give it a 7.5? Make up your mind bro.

New scoring system. Read it at the top of the review.

[Vechi8]

Quote: Originally Posted by jackw

It's crazy, when the game really sucks, OS gives it a 9.0, when it's actually pretty good, you give it a 7.5? Make up your mind bro.

I agree Jackw. This thread is all over the place. You have the reviewer justifying how a 7.5 is a nice score and that things are gonna change. Ironic that it would start with the game that is absolutely punished year after year and I admit in some cases warranted for sure. I think that the game is by far the best brand of football that I have played out of the box period. IMO it feels much better than NCAA but somehow gets a score well below. Do yourselves a favor and at least rent it, you could be in for a nice surprise

[ty5oke]

Quote: Originally Posted by Vechi8

I agree Jackw. This thread is all over the place. You have the reviewer justifying how a 7.5 is a nice score and that things are gonna change. Ironic that it would start with the game that is absolutely punished year after year and I admit in some cases warranted for sure. I think that the game is by far the best brand of football that I have played out of the box period. IMO it feels much better than NCAA but somehow gets a score well below. Do yourselves a favor and at least rent it, you could be in for a nice surprise

The scoring system was changed before this review.

[Vechi8]

Quote: Originally Posted by ty5oke

The scoring system was changed before this review.

Ahh. There goes my conspiracy theory against EA and Madden!

[sheredia]

i just think it's interesting where madden has come since 2005 without any competition......just imagine how good it would be if there was another game to compete with. you would think by now they would have fully intregated the espn presentation along with a halftime show, etc. also, commentary by al michaels and collinsworth would be nice. the lighting/weather needs to change during the course of the game as well as uniforms getting dirty.