Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Green Bay Packers and Minnesota Vikings

[DCEBB2001]

And for those who follow the in-game speeds its:

Driver: 82
Quarless: 76
Finley: 75

The Driver to Finley differential is what bugs me the most because EA has Finley ahead of Driver.

[genghisfrog]

Combine #s? Come on man. These guys aren't all rookies now. People get faster and slower.

Should Finley be an 86 speed based on other TEs ratings? No. Is he faster than Quarless, yes.

So go research your combine numbers and I'll got by what I see on the field and that is Finley is faster than Quarless.

[bucky60]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

Read the post above where it shows the reception - the 62 yard TD.

I did and I laugh at it. Griffin is a CB that could run a straight line, while the TE isn't running a straight line. He should catch him.

Quote: Originally Posted by genghisfrog

Finley had to cut twice on that play and griffin had a full head of steam. You seem to have some vendetta against Finley or a love fest for Quarless. You're really trying too hard.

[bucky60]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

Combine and PD numbers: Driver: 4.45 and N/A Quarless: 4.68 and 4.57 Finley: 4.82 and 4.66

Players can have off days, as your numbers show, or they would be much closer. That doesn't make Finley slow. 4.66 vs 4.68. And those are just two times. I'd like to see all there 40 times. And 40 times are not in game fully padded times while your running routes.

[bucky60]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

And for those who follow the in-game speeds its: Driver: 82 Quarless: 76 Finley: 75 The Driver to Finley differential is what bugs me the most because EA has Finley ahead of Driver.

I think your a little low on all of them. But you having Quarless ONE POINT higher than Finley doesn't bother me.

[aceoye]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

Proof please?

go on youtube and type in Andrew Quarless 62 yd td, dont worry Ill wait..EA is going off of 40 times and actual NFL play..Quarless doesnt do much at all for the pack its hard to rate someone acurately if they are not in spotlight with the ball running alot. quarless is either catching a 6 yard 1st down and rarely goaline tds..when Jermichael is playing he stretches the field hes in spotlight. everything quarless does X's 10. dont bring that quarless is faster than finley mess in here 40 time crap. 40 time means nothing when you have to evade players and run routes.

[at23steelers]

Quote: Originally Posted by bucky60

Players can have off days, as your numbers show, or they would be much closer. That doesn't make Finley slow. 4.66 vs 4.68. And those are just two times. I'd like to see all there 40 times. And 40 times are not in game fully padded times while your running routes.

That also doesn't mean Donny's are fully accurate either as proof that he will randomly give out 100 attribute ratings based on who the fans vote for.

[bucky60]

Quote: Originally Posted by at23steelers

That also doesn't mean Donny's are fully accurate either as proof that he will randomly give out 100 attribute ratings based on who the fans vote for.

I'm not saying Donny's are right or wrong. And I'm not even disputing that guys claim that Quarless is faster. I'm just disputing how much faster he things Quarless is. For some reason, he thinks Quarless gets good separation, and Finley can only out jump people.